logoalt Hacker News

bs7280yesterday at 6:00 PM7 repliesview on HN

A wise man told me, you know signal works because its banned in Russia. I also find it incredibly ironic that they have a problem with this, when the DoD is flagrantly using signal for classified communications.


Replies

bsimpsonyesterday at 10:46 PM

My personal connections who are in the military use it for texting from undisclosed locations.

I've heard from people who have worked with the Signal foundation that it was close to being endorsed for private communication by one branch of government, but that endorsement was rescinded because another branch didn't want people knowing how to stay private.

show 1 reply
driverdantoday at 1:02 AM

I have full confidence in Signal and their encryption but this argument doesn't make sense to me. It could be the opposite, that Russia knows it's compromised by the US government and don't want people using it. I don't believe that's the case but the point is you can't put too much weight on it.

show 1 reply
joekrillyesterday at 8:24 PM

They aren't taking issue with Signal, per se... they are upset that people are sharing the whereabouts and movements of ICE officers. Signal just seems to be the medium-of-choice. And this just happens to give them a chance to declare Signal as "bad", since they can't spy on Signal en masse.

huhtenbergyesterday at 9:19 PM

It doesn't mean much. Roblox is banned in Russia.

They've been just gradually banning everything not made in Russia.

cyberge99yesterday at 7:02 PM

You know it works because they banned it in Russia? Works for whom?

show 1 reply
OhMeadhbhyesterday at 9:17 PM

Sure, but using Signal for classified info is a violation of policy.

psunavy03yesterday at 6:02 PM

The DOD is not using "flagrantly using Signal." The Secretary of Defense, whatever his preferred pronouns are, is breaking the law.

show 1 reply