logoalt Hacker News

7777332215last Friday at 4:57 PM6 repliesview on HN

Would you raise your own animals to kill and eat? Animals eat other animals, it's nature.


Replies

hshdhdhj4444last Friday at 5:28 PM

Animals do a whole bunch of things to other animals we wouldn’t consider acceptable.

Cannibalism, eating your young, rape, etc.

I’m not sure why killing for food is the one place we should choose to define our values and ethics based on what animals in the wild do.

show 2 replies
xnxlast Friday at 5:00 PM

Murder and rape are also part of nature, but humans can reflect and consider the effects of their actions in ways other animals can't.

CurrentBlast Friday at 5:04 PM

Personally that would be even worse for me, though I understand maybe "better" on a societal scale by some metrics. To feed a being every day and care for it, to gain its trust, to appreciate their individuality, then to have them killed when they reach some fraction of its potential lifespan, I just don't want to do that. I'm perfectly happy eating legumes.

show 1 reply
midtakelast Friday at 7:14 PM

Yes. That is far more harmonious with nature than using machines of industry to enslave animal species and slaughter them on profit-driven schedules.

Don't get me wrong, I eat meat, but I also understand that the grand majority of fellow meat-eaters have never hunted or reared livestock. Instead they are complete soyboys (ironic isn't it) who merely consume the output from the machine. These same beta cucks will open their mouths to screech "but animals eat animals in the wild!" Completely missing how unnatural an industrialized slaughter machine is.

The only reason they are enslaved is that they lack organization and understanding. Had they those two, they could kill us all.

mmoosslast Friday at 7:06 PM

There are many good arguments I think, but not this one. Nature is eating your neighbor's children; it's starvation, epidemics, and massive forest fires; it's unrestrained homicide and rape; it's leaving your physically weakened child to die; it's eating the head of your spouse; it's survival of the fittest; ... (you get my point).

The other animals in nature are not my standard of behavior. In a sense, the point of any culture is to exceed nature and by as much as possible.