logoalt Hacker News

AlotOfReadingyesterday at 6:08 PM6 repliesview on HN

The additional drag is negligible. People have been producing "racing doors" with handles for decades. They focus on cutting all the other features of the door like weight and mechanical complexity instead. It's an even more irrelevant consideration for consumers, who could save far more fuel by changing how they drive.

Flush handles exist as brand differentiators. They're a "futuristic" feel-good feature that consumers want, like engine noise, tablets, and colorful dashboards.


Replies

seanmcdirmidtoday at 2:05 AM

> Flush handles exist as brand differentiators. They're a "futuristic" feel-good feature that consumers want, like engine noise, tablets, and colorful dashboards.

Incorrect. They are most definitely there to save money on production and development costs, like all the other stuff you misattribute to brand differentiators. Consumers like lower prices, car companies like more profit. Yes, it looks fancy, but it is cheaper to produce, judt like the tablet dash.

show 1 reply
kube-systemyesterday at 6:53 PM

All of the things you mention are considerations that every automaker considers. Product design engineering is simply an exercise in weighting those factors, among many others.

show 1 reply
WalterBrightyesterday at 6:58 PM

People who race stock cars will even dip body panels into acid to make the panels thinner. Anything to reduce weight!

recursiveyesterday at 6:34 PM

> It's an even more irrelevant consideration for consumers, who could save far more fuel by changing how they drive.

These are not in conflict. The energy you save from drag stacks with the energy you save from "learning how to drive".

show 2 replies
PearlRiveryesterday at 10:40 PM

Exactly it is not science but purely cosmetic. Which for some reason makes HN mad but guess what people choose cars based on how they look and how they are marketed! There has never been a rational man. Spock is not real.