logoalt Hacker News

Der_Einzigeyesterday at 5:28 PM5 repliesview on HN

Make voting be based on military eligibility. This is something Starship Troopers was sort of correct about.

You can't be drafted in war time emergencies? You can't vote (also yes I do want women to be draftable)


Replies

Waterluvianyesterday at 5:32 PM

> This is something Starship Troopers was sort of correct about.

It might also suggest further reflection is warranted.

show 3 replies
ecshaferyesterday at 6:00 PM

I think people should be able to get up to 3 votes:

1. Veteran

2. Property ownership

3. Having children.

If you dont hit 1 of those criteria, you dont get a vote. You need skin in the game. Letting anyone vote is why “tax someone else, give me things” is such a popular platform. Politicians should have to hit maybe 2 out of 3.

show 7 replies
xboxnolifesyesterday at 8:00 PM

So, only people aged 18 to 25 year olds should be able to vote in the US?

landl0rdyesterday at 5:29 PM

You're right about military eligibility, but also that you shouldn't make calls for a nation which you will never see. Doubly so if one does not have children. No skin in the game, no alignment of incentives, no moral right to choose.

Even moreso when you consider basically the whole generation relies on leeching off the young and have continued to capture an ever-increasing proportion of public spending across the western world despite owning an outsized proportion of both real estate and wealth overall.

lokaryesterday at 5:44 PM

What about people with a medial disability?

show 3 replies