logoalt Hacker News

DauntingPear7today at 4:51 AM12 repliesview on HN

As a college student without too much spending money, what’re some board games I should check out? I have wingspan, catan, and azul and wanna expand my collection with other must have games


Replies

r-johnvtoday at 5:31 AM

+1 to shoo for the bgg links!

BoardGameGeek is the place to read up on games before buying them.

On the 'without spending money' front, depending on the city where you live, there often are board game cafes where you can go to rent games and play over there.

More economical if you are playing the game once or want to try out different games. Also very good if you struggle with learning rules from the rulebook.

enlythtoday at 9:22 AM

I want to recommend a game you can pull out and explain in a couple of minutes that everyone tends to enjoy. I've played many a board games with people and this one has had unparalleled success in terms of enjoyment and replayability across broad audiences

It's called "So Clover!" and it's a word association themed game where each person gets four pairs of words, you write a one word clue for each pair, and then the rest of the group has to work backwards to figure out the original orientation of your cards (the cards themselves each have four words as well)

https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/329839/so-clover

pavel_lishintoday at 4:58 AM

I'm not the person you asked, but I'd highly recommend Splendor. Very easy to learn, very fun to play.

show 1 reply
jader201today at 6:01 AM

Also agree with the other great suggestions in the sibling comments.

One thing that would help if you could figure out the types of games you and your group might enjoy — or the type of group you and your friends are.

If you think you’d enjoy deeper strategy games, start with some of the popular games in the “strategy” category on BGG, looking for light to medium weight (1.5-2.5) to start out, working your way up the scale (to 3.0, 3.5, and 4.0).

If you’re more into the social/party type games (those are always more fun in larger groups), look at the party category. I particularly enjoy social deduction games in the right group, and those are usually big hits with older kids / younger adults (though I still enjoy social deduction games and I’m quite beyond “younger adult”). :)

One good example is One Night Ultimate Werewolf.

One tip: if you’re interested in trying out some strategy games that are a bit out of your price range, check out boardgameoracle.com and add price alerts on a few games you have your eye on. Many great board game sites run good deals (gamenerdz.com is one of my favorites), so you can often get good deals on games if you’re patient.

If you ever get to the point where you’re looking for something with a bit more depth, and are ok spending money, but you want the money to go a long way, Age of Steam is one of the best bangs for your buck.

It’s basically a system that has a library of probably close to 200 maps, where each map can change the game quite drastically, by tweaking several rules, in addition to a different map of course.

It’s currently my #1 game, and you could repeat plays with it without it getting old, assuming others enjoy the mechanics of game (route building, auction/bidding, tight economy).

deauxtoday at 9:54 AM

A lot of the so far mentioned games, while great, aren't that cheap or portable.

I really recommend trying a trick-taking game! Skull King, Fox in the Forest, Tichu. Easy to learn, impossible to master.

leethargotoday at 7:48 AM

I really like "Root" (for the asymmetry) and "Arcs" (for the openness), although they are quite "heavy" in terms of rules and interactions.

show 1 reply
mg74today at 8:05 AM

Get a 1830 variant (e.g. 18Chesapeake) and Age of Steam. Also any Splotter game (Indonesia just got a new printing). A new Brass will come to Kickstarter very soon, that could be a good choice. A pax game would be good to, Pax Pamir 2ed is a good choice.

throw_awaittoday at 7:28 AM

I can recommend Stardew Valley. It really captures the same cozyness as the video game, and it's cooperative.

show 1 reply
r-johnvtoday at 5:24 AM

'Terraforming Mars' is a game that I've come back to more times than I can count.

The beauty is that it visually looks really complex and advanced, but the gameplay isn't really that much complex more than wingspan.

Over the years I bought the 'prelude' expansion which speeds up the beginning. (Highly recommend)

And then once you've played it more than 10-15 times, the Hellas& Elysium adds more maps for variety.

toast0today at 6:05 AM

Does your school have a board game group? If so, consider joining it to expand your effective collection (and perhaps your social group).

If not, maybe there's an adjacent group that might also be willing to entertain board games, or it's a group you could found. My college had a gaming, anime, and chess group which anchored my social experience.

shootoday at 5:24 AM

+1 to pavel_lishin's Splendor suggestion. There's also Splendour: Duel [1] which is a more complex version of the game designed for 2 players.

Another quick, low-complexity game that is easy to teach & pretty good fun is Century: Spice Road [2]

Chinatown [3] (re-themed as Waterfall Park [3b] ) is a simple highly interactive game that is basically 100% negotiations between players who are trying to make real estate deals with each other. Can be played in 90 minutes, including rules explanation, plays up to 5. For a more complex asymmetric game that's more focused on engine building, with a healthy dose of negotiation, check out Sidereal Confluence [4].

For more complex games that take a bit longer to play to teach and play, that are largely focused on players doing their own thing ("multiplayer solitaire"), building their engines without much negative player interaction, check out Ark Nova [5] or Terraforming Mars [6]. These might take 3-4 hours or so to finish, provided there's an experienced player to teach everyone the rules.

For another moderately complex strategy game with a little more player interaction, check out Brass: Birmingham [7]. Takes around 4.5 hours to finish a 4 player game, including the rules explanation. If you have a group that enjoys complex strategy games and wants something with spikier negative player interactions, where one player's actions can completely wreck another player's plans, check out Barrage [8].

This probably doesn't help "without spending much money"! One trick is to find or create a regular board gaming group where everyone brings along different games. That way if, everyone buys a new game or two every year there's a lot of variety without everyone needing to buy heaps of games.

[1] https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/364073/splendor-duel

[2] https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/209685/century-spice-roa...

[3] https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/47/chinatown

[3b] https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/396618/waterfall-park

[4] https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/202426/sidereal-confluen...

[5] https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/342942/ark-nova

[6] https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/167791/terraforming-mars

[7] https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/224517/brass-birmingham

[8] https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/251247/barrage

show 1 reply
aaronblohowiaktoday at 6:01 AM

carcassonne!