logoalt Hacker News

Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs

66 pointsby bikenagayesterday at 4:20 PM33 commentsview on HN

Comments

amatechayesterday at 11:42 PM

The X's on the animal forms (Fig. 1B) ... isn't that likely to be "hit here" type markings, for hunting reference? Shoulder, side, stomach... surprised this wasn't really touched on in the paper, since it seems really likely. Though, the paper doesn't seem to care so much about the actual meanings, seemingly just narrowing down the number of possible interpretations /shrug

show 1 reply
ggmtoday at 2:33 AM

Absolutely fascinating study. I look forward to more as the density of materials rises.

I would observe that calligraphy such as in Islamic art, frequently conveys two messages. One is more abstract such as it's compelling beauty, but it can also be strongly representational. A word about swans in the shape of a Swan.

So I don't see "it's just decoration" as a strong rebuttal. It may be decorative. It can also convey meaning.

kazinatoryesterday at 11:59 PM

> Humans have carved visual signs into the surfaces of mobile artifacts [...]

And, undoubtedly, while doing so, some of them walked into something and got hurt.

WalterBrightyesterday at 10:08 PM

They could also be simply idle doodling or decorations.

show 2 replies
unit149today at 1:51 AM

[dead]

bikenagayesterday at 4:21 PM

[dead]

show 1 reply
truhistoryyesterday at 9:37 PM

[flagged]

show 4 replies
ponklifeyesterday at 9:24 PM

[flagged]

iberatoryesterday at 10:38 PM

Ha! And someone today at HN laughed at the research of monkeys playing with crystals...

Maybe one day we could communicate with monkeys with marbles and crystals and stuff as SIGN language.

Imagine monkey soldiers becoming reality in AI WARS.

show 1 reply