logoalt Hacker News

bicepjaitoday at 3:40 AM3 repliesview on HN

This is one of my favorite philosophical questions to ponder. I always ask it in interviews as a warmup to get their thoughts. I’ve noticed that interviewees often curl up, thinking it’s a technical question, so I’ve been modifying the question one after the other to make it less scary. The interviews are for data scientist roles.


Replies

hodgehog11today at 10:49 AM

It's amazing that you find so many that are uncomfortable with this question. I literally teach a first-year data science course and I ask the students this very question. I spend half a lecture on it and put it in their assessment.

This is one of the most fundamental things to understand in statistics. If you don't have at least some degree of comfort with this, you have no business working with data in a professional capacity.

show 1 reply
Buttons840today at 3:52 AM

I haven't read the article, but my understanding is that a normal curve results from summing several samples from most common probability distributions, and also a normal curve results from summing many normal curves.

All summation roads lead to normal curves. (There might be an exception for weird probability distributions that do not have a mean; I was surprised when I learned these exist.)

Life is full of sums. Height? That's a sum of genetics and nutrition, and both of those can be broken down into other sums. How long the treads last on a tire? That's a sum of all the times the tire has been driven, and all of those times driving are just sums of every turn and acceleration.

I'm not a data scientist. I'm just a programmer that works with piles of poorly designed business logic.

How did I do in my interview? (I am looking for a job.)

show 1 reply
hilliardfarmertoday at 3:48 AM

A lot of times I can't tell if I'm the idiot or if everyone else is. Says that this isn't an interesting question at all and the article was horrible. I studied data science for a few years but I'm no expert, but it seems pretty obvious to me that if you make a series of 50/50 choices randomly, that's the shape you end up with and there's really nothing more interesting about it than that.

show 2 replies