logoalt Hacker News

SoftTalkerlast Wednesday at 4:44 PM2 repliesview on HN

> I'm not even sure building software is an engineering discipline at this point. Maybe it never was.

It isn't. Show me the licensing requirements to be a "software engineer." There are none. A 12 year old can call himself a software engineer and there are probably some who have managed to get remote work on major projects.


Replies

JoshTriplettlast Wednesday at 5:08 PM

> It isn't. Show me the licensing requirements

That's assuming the axiom that "engineer" must require licensing requirements. That may be true in some jurisdictions, but it's not axiomatically or definitionally true.

Some kinds of building software may be "engineering", some kinds may not be, but anyone seeking to argue that "licensing requirements" should come into play will have to actually argue that rather than treat it as an unstated axiom.

show 2 replies
anthklast Wednesday at 5:00 PM

In Europe they are. Call yourself an Engineer without a degree and your company and you will be sued with a big fine, because here you must be legally accountable on disasters and ofc there are hard constraints .

show 3 replies