logoalt Hacker News

andyferrislast Wednesday at 11:43 PM3 repliesview on HN

Vibe coding is actually "good" for small, bespoke things. The same way that Excel is "good" for small tasks, bad bad for larger things. Too easy to make mistakes, too hard to maintain.

I could equally ask - where are all the Excel workbooks that are actually _good_? No-one needs to share their Excel workbooks. They don't need 10k github stars. They just achieve some small goal of the Excel user. These LLM agents just need to do what the user needs doing at any moment.

(Sometimes, that can be a small part of a larger job in software, or a series of small parts perhaps - but again you are going to see this "show up" as a part of peoples workflow in maintaining enterprise software which is what most programmers are employed to do, in other words, you won't directly see it at all. And no, digital cameras didn't change the field 18 months after the first somewhat-usable one was released - it took quite a while for the technology to become good enough and cheap to democratize filmmaking).


Replies

aryehofyesterday at 10:05 AM

> maintaining enterprise software which is what most programmers are employed to do …

I hear little from those involved with enterprise or line-of-business applications discussing their findings. Forums like this are dominated by SAAS, tool makers, computer and data scientists, and infrastructure concerns.

Anyone using AI with large, complex business systems?

show 1 reply
perrygeoyesterday at 4:05 AM

Wonderful analogy.

I still use spreadsheets regularly. Relieved of the pressure of making something "good", I can get basic things done quickly.

Is it sustainable or maintainable? Nope. Doesn't need to be. Not qualities I'm remotely concerned about when I'm writing a spreadsheet.

Vibe coding is similar in that you can solve a specific problem without much concern for generalization or future reuse.

Forgeties79yesterday at 12:47 AM

I don’t care about GitHub stars. There are tons of excel workbooks and such that are useful, publicly available, and utilized.