logoalt Hacker News

bombcartoday at 1:49 PM4 repliesview on HN

I loved the era of "daughter cards" which were just entire computers on a board.

things like https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a6b4lYOI0GQ could get you a really interesting form of multitasking


Replies

mikepurvistoday at 4:47 PM

From the perspective of PC building, I've always thought it would be neat if the CPU/storage/RAM could go on a card with a PCIe edge connector, and then that could be plugged into a "motherboard" that's basically just a PCIe multiplexer out to however many peripheral cards you have.

Maybe it's gimmicky, but I feel like you could get some interesting form factors with the CPU and GPU cards sitting back-to-back or side-by-side, and there would be more flexibility for how to make space for a large air cooler, or take it up again if you've got an AIO.

I know some of this already happens with SFF builds that use a Mini-ITX motherboard + ribbon cable to the GPU, but it's always been a little awkward with Mini-ITX being a 170mm square, and high end GPUs being only 137mm wide but up to 300mm in length.

show 4 replies
Teevertoday at 4:21 PM

That's what I was hoping Apple was going to do with a refreshed Mac Pro.

I had envisoned a smaller tower design that with PCI slots and Apple developing and selling daughter cards that were basically just a redesigned macbook pro PCB but with a PCI-E edge connector and power connector.

The way I see it a user could start with a reasonably powerful base machine and then upgrade it over time and mix and match different daughter cards. A ten year old desktop is fine as a day to day driver, it just needs some fancy NPU to do fancy AI stuff.

This kind of architecture seems to make sense to me in an age where computers have such a longer usable lifespan and where so many features are integrated into the motherboard.

show 2 replies
wat10000today at 7:17 PM

Now we have cables that include computers more powerful than an old mainframe. So if it pleases you, just think of all the tiny little daughter computers hooked up to your machine now.

bitwizetoday at 3:16 PM

Or even Doom on your Beeb: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=32hJLwrk-gY