logoalt Hacker News

dd8601fntoday at 2:50 PM3 repliesview on HN

At the start I think everyone thought the industrial revolution could be a useful historical reference.

But what AI is selling is the obliteration of human knowledge work.

It just isn’t informative for that.


Replies

jonahxtoday at 3:09 PM

This is the key point. It threatens nearly everything in the limit, not one particular industry. There will be no "leveling up" into higher-order jobs, because the machines will be better at those too.

show 1 reply
softwaredougtoday at 3:04 PM

A guild craftsmen weaving / making firearms pre Industrial Revolution would see their work as much about “knowledge” as manual labor.

Much of that got obliterated by automation.

History doesn’t repeat itself, but it certainly rhymes

cmrdporcupinetoday at 3:56 PM

Nah, it's obliterating the distinction -- made by middle class folks and only temporarily true -- between physical labour and intellectual labour.

You as a blue collar machine operator, shoving punch cards in and getting answers out, is precisely what your boss always saw you as, or wanted you to be.

Our necessity as pseudo-craftsmen holding an intellectual high ground and wizardly/magical skills was always resented by investors, owners, and sometimes customers.

Blacksmithing and leather tanning and shoe making and seamstressing and furniture making was human knowledge work, too.

The Alvin Toffler stuff was always bullshit, but it's even more bullshit now.