logoalt Hacker News

EGregtoday at 6:34 PM2 repliesview on HN

Emphatically, no. These are industrial experiments, in a similar vein to various Canola oils but much worse.

You probably heard of aspartame but there are worse things. A chemical byproduct of sucralose known as sucralose-6-acetate has been identified as highly genotoxic, meaning it breaks down DNA and may increase cancer risks. Found in common sucralose-based sweeteners, it causes a "leaky gut" by damaging intestinal walls and poses serious health risks, even at low, allowed consumption levels.

https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/a-chemical-found-i...

Heart Attacks (Erythritol): The sweetener erythritol, common in "keto-friendly" drinks, has been linked to increased blood clotting, potentially doubling the risk of heart attack or stroke.

https://www.aarp.org/health/conditions-treatments/are-artifi...

However, high levels of fructose have been engineered in many formerly natural foods, which is also dangerous (though far less so).

https://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/13ecikd/til_...

Sugar-free drinks are increasingly linked to serious health risks, with studies suggesting they are not harmless alternatives. Key concerns include a 20% higher risk of AFib (irregular heartbeat), increased stroke and cardiovascular disease risks, and potential links to type 2 diabetes. They may also trigger digestive issues, gut microbiome disruption, and tooth decay.

The artificial sweeteners may not even do the very thing people choose them for. Contrary to their purpose, some studies show artificial sweeteners may raise type 2 diabetes risk by up to 38%. Other Potential Dangers: Research has linked consumption to metabolic syndrome, kidney disease, nonalcoholic fatty liver disease, and potential gut bacteria disruption. Dental Damage: Acidic components can cause enamel erosion despite the absence of sugar.

Xylitol and Stevia may be exceptions, but they are also more naturally occurring. People sometimes try to use xylitol gum to stave off caries bacteria, but frankly, a diet rich in animal fats (butter etc) can do a lot more for teeth and bones.


Replies

aitchnyutoday at 6:39 PM

Zookeepers determined modern fruits are harming their animals https://qz.com/1408469/humans-have-bred-fruits-to-be-so-high...

llm_nerdtoday at 6:54 PM

>These are industrial experiments, in a similar vein to various Canola oils but much worse.

Ah, a "seed oil" guy. This is the indication to everyone what level of discourse and scientific fact you're bringing to the table.

In fact, I'll just cite one single bit in your claim-

>Contrary to their purpose, some studies show artificial sweeteners may raise type 2 diabetes risk by up to 38%

This suffers from the same "aha!" nonsense as the garbage submission (and it is garbage). The "study" you are citing was an observational, epidemiological study. And wow, crazy and hard to believe, but it turns out that people with weight problems (and all that comes with that) are more likely to have partaken of "at least one" sugar substitute drink. This is similar to studying people who chew nicotine gum and for obvious reasons finding a higher rate of lung cancer, so then declare that nicotine gum causes lung cancer. It is so staggeringly stupid it belies belief, but it makes for a headline to fool some rubes.

show 1 reply