logoalt Hacker News

dinoqqqtoday at 10:46 AM5 repliesview on HN

It's worrying that they don't specify in which cases they require identity checks.


Replies

wheybagstoday at 10:52 AM

Basically the only relevant question, and it's the one they didn't answer

show 1 reply
daliusdtoday at 10:54 AM

I can guess at least one valid:

* preventing North Korea, China, Russian, Iran and etc. actors from accessing service. They absolutely use workarounds to access AI, e.g. I bet there are companies who are proxy between Anthropic and those countries.

I imagine there will be quite some false positives while identifying those.

show 1 reply
llm_nerdtoday at 11:03 AM

Just a few days ago, on Friday, my 15 year old son had his Claude account suspended with a demand for ID to prove he is 18 or older. He had his own Claude Max subscription (he out-earns me fairly frequently in his circle of gaming programmers), and was unaware Anthropic had a must-be-18 rule, as was I. Their email said "Our team found signals that your account was used by a child. This breaks our rules, so we paused your access to Claude." So I guess if you ever ask a question that seems to originate from a teen or less, expect to hit an ID gate.

So now he's a Codex user. OpenAI and Google both have a minimum age of 13.

EDIT: I should note that Anthropic gave him a refund for the whole month that was underway, despite him being nearing the end of it. So good on them.

show 1 reply
helsinkiandrewtoday at 11:02 AM

The "Why did my account get banned after verification?" section gives some reasons:

- Repeated violations of our Usage Policy

- Account creation from an unsupported location

- Terms of Service violations

- Under-18 usage

show 1 reply