logoalt Hacker News

amazingamazingtoday at 12:27 AM4 repliesview on HN

> The only thing missing is ownership that answers to the people — not to shareholders.

Noble, but this will fail. Why would anyone do this? No incentive.

These sorts of initiatives forget the toil of actually operating a business. You might as well get more pledges given that you'd have more control and the same profit share. It will regress to the same as the status quo.


Replies

nerdsnipertoday at 12:42 AM

I pledged $1,000. I have been daydreaming about a customer-owned airline for years now, just about every time I walk through an airport. This might not have much chance of succeeding in its purchase of Spirit’s assets, but I’d love to watch things unfold if it did.

> These sorts of initiatives forget the toil of actually operating a business.

For most businesses the size of Spirit Airlines, the owners typically do not operate the business. They pay people to do that. I don’t operate REI, even though I’m one of its many owners.

show 2 replies
corvadtoday at 12:28 AM

I'm not sure that's even noble as by buying you would be a shareholder...

show 1 reply
morkalorktoday at 12:35 AM

Co-ops don't exist at all, right?

show 4 replies
paulddrapertoday at 12:35 AM

“The only thing missing is ownership that answers to the people — not to shareholders.”

Like, all people in the world?

Customers? Employees?

What does this mean?

EDIT: It’s shareholders, but each person has one vote regardless of share count.

show 1 reply