logoalt Hacker News

titanomachytoday at 12:42 AM2 repliesview on HN

I watched that video a dozen times and I still don’t understand where the angular momentum came from. That guy must have been trying to throw himself, right??


Replies

_carbyau_today at 12:45 AM

I don't know in this case.

But I do know some of the moves are:

"If you don't throw yourself, your wrist/elbow/shoulder/whatever will be dislocated or broken."

And so the student, knowing this, saves themselves. IE the idea of rolling with the punches.

Which is to say, some moves are to be judged on the possible result, not the one you saw.

Whether that applies in this case, I don't know.

show 2 replies
raspasovtoday at 3:07 AM

Yes, he’s throwing himself. Aikido is often practiced solely as a non-competitive art.

If you want to see what competitive throws/takedowns with a kimono/gi look like against live resistance, watch Judo. Example https://youtu.be/fLD87nqwp3Y

For the same but without kimono, watch Greco-Roman. Example https://youtu.be/4Xc-wxNSsTk).