logoalt Hacker News

minimaxirtoday at 12:41 AM2 repliesview on HN

> it will eventually be project suicide to pull tricks like this

The only reason that the jqwik incident didn't blow up much outside of the tech sphere is because it is a relatively niche library and there wasn't damage. If something like React or numpy did the same thing and real code got deleted, chaos would ensue.

The author admitted there were personal and professional consequences in their blog post despite the small surface area.


Replies

ceejayoztoday at 12:49 AM

Chaos, and maybe criminal charges ala Aaron Swartz.

show 2 replies
mapontoseventhstoday at 1:49 AM

He should not only be ostracized by the community, he should probably face charges. To be charged under the CFAA in America we need only show that he was authorized only to access a certain part of the system and the he exceeded the amount of access granted. He very clearly did that. Users trusted him enough to run his code, and he betrayed that trust to make some political point.

Whether it was via prompt injection or SQL injection is irrelevant. Whether you agree with his politics or not is irrelevant. All that matters is he wasn't authorized to delete code from your system, and he abused the level of access granted to him to do that anyhow.

show 2 replies