logoalt Hacker News

BeetleByesterday at 9:54 PM4 repliesview on HN

I love the warning about not having hands on the steering wheel.

It goes off all the time. And each time, my hands are on the steering wheel.

It doesn't actually detect contact - it checks to see if you're actively adjusting the steering wheel.

Except I don't need to! The lane keep assist is so good that it's rare I have to give it additional help.

So - I kid you not - I've gotten used to giving a nudge to the steering wheel every so many seconds to prevent that warning (you cannot disable it).

Imagine a car gave you cruise control, and then checked if you were paying attention by requiring you to press down on the accelerator every so many seconds. Does that make sense?


Replies

anonymousiamyesterday at 11:10 PM

I have the same issue in my 2020 AMG. With lane assit on, the way it detects that your hands are on the steering wheel is by sensing your inputs to counter its inputs to the steering wheel position. It even seems to deliberately steer you off the center of the lane to see if you react.

That is a seriously broken control system. It should be keeping you in the center of the lane and not make you fight against the car.

brikymyesterday at 10:23 PM

My Nissan does check both hands are contacting the steering wheel making lane centering basically useless if I want to do anything with one hand like adjust my glasses, change the audio etc.

illusive4080yesterday at 9:55 PM

I do this too. Want to get a comma.ai device just so I don’t have to wiggle the steering wheel.

show 1 reply
comradesmithyesterday at 10:04 PM

You should buy a dumber car