logoalt Hacker News

TeMPOraLtoday at 6:28 AM3 repliesview on HN

The monitors aren't installing anything. That headline was a lie.

It's Windows Update that's installing LG crapware upon seeing relevant hardware IDs. That's why the problem affected older monitors too - it's the update side that suddenly started to ship malware.


Replies

delta_p_delta_xtoday at 6:41 AM

> It's Windows Update that's installing LG crapware upon seeing relevant hardware IDs

This is also a misrepresentation. Microsoft has provided LG with a certificate to sign its driver packages with, and allows LG to upload packages to Windows Update, which includes a feature to install sidecar applications. Now, the spirit of this feature is that any application is meant to provide genuine configuration functionality or some graphical front end to the driver's configuration knobs.

LG then abused that feature to provide adware. Now, there are millions of hardware vendors. One can't expect that every driver package submission from every vendor is thoroughly vetted every time, this is a matter of trust and respect.

Sometimes one actually wants the app that comes with the device, like AMD's and NVIDIA's configuration trays.

Even so, I fully expect that after this debacle MS will disable this stuff. There is precedent for this. Synaptics/ELAN/Alps touchpad tray applications largely disappeared after MS implemented precision touchpads somewhere in 2015, and suddenly Windows touchpads became as precise as those on Macs. Likewise with RGB peripherals. Even GPU driver applications have increasingly become less useful as the most important features—power control, adaptive sync, HDR, etc have moved into native Windows settings.

show 10 replies
felooboolooombatoday at 6:45 AM

> That headline was a lie.

Kinda agree but let's call it "misinformed" or something, instead of a lie.

show 1 reply
account42today at 10:23 AM

The headline isn't a lie, even if you can technically nitpick it.

The manufacturer implemented choices to deliberately install the software when the monitors are connected. The mechanism is not important to why this is outrageous.