logoalt Hacker News

altmanaltmantoday at 3:10 AM2 repliesview on HN

The whole "codeberg is political" is the scary bit. Whose politics? How is it decided by members what exact politics to represent? Do some members have undue influence on exerting their particular politics?

Sure ban Cryptocurrency projects whatever, its your platform. But calling a code hosting service "political" and acting like its the Galatic Senate is just wrong priorities. It is hard to take something serious like that if they just say "hey we are political whether you like it or not" without spending susbtantial amount of time ensuring its clean, transparent and good politics not a bunch of sith lords jerking each other off.


Replies

pretendgeneertoday at 3:20 AM

I think you're misunderstanding "codeberg is political".

Everything is political, FOSS is political, GitHub is also political.

When people say "We're not political", or "That's not political". What they're actually saying is that it's within my own politics.

show 7 replies
jjmarrtoday at 3:36 AM

It's the politics of the paid membership of the Codeberg non-profit that funds the whole operation. They vote in yearly meetings.

show 1 reply