logoalt Hacker News

BMW Spider-Man in-car advertising

179 pointsby goplayoutsidetoday at 3:25 AM113 commentsview on HN

Comments

helterskeltertoday at 3:46 AM

Great way to tank a brand. Part of BMW's value is/was the expectation of an upper middle class snob driving it, but having your car force ads on you is something people wouldn't even expect from a Kia Soul leased off a used lot.

show 4 replies
c7btoday at 5:47 AM

It sounds awful, but it might not even make the top-5 of the most annoying/concering things you'll get in a new car (bought in the EU at least), many of which are now mandatory by regulation. What you'll also get is a camera that tracks your eye movements to play an alert when they're not on the road, an alarm when you drive over the allowed speed limit as determined by a camera, an alarm plus a mechanical yanking of your driving wheel when you're approaching the side of your lane without a turn signal on. As a cherry on top it's unclear what happens with all the data generated by these systems. And I'm probably forgetting a few.

I'm wondering what a good cutoff date is when considering buying a used car.

show 5 replies
narmiouhtoday at 3:45 AM

Samsung the same with their display on fridge, I'm not sure how is this legal and why someone thinks this is ok.

These decision makers are meant to be educated people with may be at least a tiny bit of values in their lives...

show 3 replies
DrewADesigntoday at 3:44 AM

I wonder if they say: "A new life awaits you in the Off-world colonies. The chance to begin again in a golden land of opportunity and adventure."

show 1 reply
inasiotoday at 6:02 AM

The main story in the wiki page comes from the Autopian [0], specifically from Jason Torchinsky, ex Jalopnik. It's an awesome publication, check them out, and Jason is an incredible writer (Onion alumni)

[0] https://www.theautopian.com/bmw-is-showing-commercials-on-th...

DanOpcodetoday at 5:53 AM

Wouldn't it be fair if BMW at least shared the advertisement revenue with the car owners?

It's so ugly that they first sell cars, and profit from that. And then they utilize the fleet of cars to squeeze out more revenue, even though that was never part of the contract to begin with. What right does BMW have to do that?

If they found a new revenue source, it would be nice if they at least shared that with their customers. Now it's just abuse of their customers. Where BMW is one-sided profiting while the customers are suffering.

show 1 reply
fumeux_fumetoday at 3:45 AM

> BMW's own PressClub release described the advertisement as a special surprise for drivers...

That one got a chuckle out of me

show 2 replies
walrus01today at 3:53 AM

If please drink a verification can was applied to automobiles.

show 2 replies
OsrsNeedsf2Ptoday at 3:38 AM

Great to see the Consumer Rights wiki has been picking up steam. Lots of passionate people behind the project

tmcnallytoday at 6:14 AM

BMWs have decent 'mod' support, if you fully own a msport/M you can be mitigating OTA updates in firmware to retain your perf/exhaust pops as regulations/OEMs change goals. Original firmware b58s (m340/z4m40) are infamously coveted for specific software/hardware versions... Same logic can be applied to this strange advert thingy

show 1 reply
tonyedgecombetoday at 6:06 AM

Whilst we are having a dig at BMW owners it turns out that most of them don't know whether their car is front or rear wheel drive.

https://www.motortrend.com/news/bmw-80-of-1series-owners-don...

smlacytoday at 5:34 AM

The ultimate driving machine... for marginal revenue.

foo12bartoday at 3:57 AM

This looks like it, possibly. There doesn't seem to be a banner that you click on like it states in the consumer rights article, but rather an icon, so not sure.

https://m.youtube.com/shorts/Z8v2tsYdgRk

show 1 reply
haritha-jtoday at 6:15 AM

This and the eye tracking could make a killer combo. “Stare at this ad for 30s to unlock the drive gear”.

show 1 reply
userbinatortoday at 4:27 AM

Hopefully their lawyers have considered the possibility of a bug causing this ad to play while the car is being driven and leading to a distracted driving accident...

on suitably equipped vehicles running BMW Operating System 7, 8, 8.5, 9, or OS X built after July 2020

For those who were surprised by that naming, Apple hasn't used "OS X" for nearly 10 years.

luciana1utoday at 5:18 AM

at this point the luxury car feature is that nothing in it demands your attention. a screen that just shows the speed and the fuel gauge and shuts up

show 1 reply
bredrentoday at 6:05 AM

A month ago the highly upvoted blog entry [0] about Rivian’s rejection of CarPlay included this quote from Rivian’s Chief Software Officer, Wassym Bensaid:

   The challenge with screen mirroring solutions is that they take over every single pixel in the car, and that’s not the way we see ourselves interacting with our users.
Yes, it’s clear the companies’ see the way they want to “interact” with their customers is to force whatever content they please.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48769397

Rohunyyytoday at 3:42 AM

Shocked. Absolutely shocked. No one saw this coming

show 1 reply
q3ktoday at 6:41 AM

> Clicking on it then activates the Spider-Man™ animation, comprising a full-screen festive animation in the Control Display with aptly chosen backing music and an accompanying light show courtesy of the ambient lighting system.

Stop the presses, it's not an ad, it's just a “festive animation”!

Neil44today at 5:45 AM

My BYD doesn't do this.

show 3 replies
fnord77today at 4:24 AM

I got hit with this Wednesday morning when I started my 330i. I cannot wait to sign up for the class action lawsuit.

show 1 reply
fragmedetoday at 3:36 AM

One of the best things one of me mates from high school did for me, is buy himself a BMW. The amount of problems and money he had to deal with helped me realize I didn't actually want a BMW, they're just nice to look at.

show 2 replies
wewewedxfgdftoday at 6:26 AM

Enshittification of everything.

Markofftoday at 5:38 AM

this is what you get for buying cheap noname brand car from Temu

similar thing happened with that British LGBT brand, which is gone

though it's clear people who buy BMW are not mentally sane anyway, I'm yet to see BMW driver with stable personality who would not vent their mental issues on the road, these people will buy BMW with literally any design and specs just because it's BMW, no matter it looks like ugly tank

I honestly believe if we banned BMW car registrations number of accidents would drop much more than it's their total share on registrations.

show 1 reply
onetokeoverthetoday at 3:33 AM

and the in-dash eye tracking device shows 66% of drivers engage for at least 5 seconds!!

show 1 reply
roundwegotoday at 4:43 AM

[flagged]

show 1 reply
asciiitoday at 3:54 AM

Drove a lot of BMWs when I was working summers as a mechanic

show 2 replies