logoalt Hacker News

Joel_Mckaytoday at 12:00 AM1 replyview on HN

Some are already on RVA23.1 even before the standard made it to more than 4 manufacturers product lines.

The meme joke about standards is sadly relevant for riscv. =3

https://xkcd.com/927/


Replies

d-us-vbtoday at 1:00 AM

As I’ve come to understand it, standards simplify intensionally, not extensionally. For those who select a part that is compliant with a standard, more standards to choose from is better because engineers are able to make better tradeoffs; they’re not forced to select a part that does way more than the application needs thus making the product more expensive if there are lots of “competing” standards: some do less some do more.

For RV, a litany of standardized modules creates a system where each capability that the module provides will have a standard interface. No manufacturer is forced to invent extensions bespoke to their implementation, but they’re not forced to support everything the most powerful models do either.

Just my two cents.

show 1 reply