logoalt Hacker News

mbeavitttoday at 10:54 AM3 repliesview on HN

Bring back DVD rentals!

In the US, you don't even need to pay a licensing fee when you buy a DVD with intent to rent it out to people (this is not the case in the UK), thanks to the "First-sale doctrine" - Bobbs-Merrill v. Straus (1908).


Replies

footytoday at 11:05 AM

I don't know about in the US, but I live in a fairly small city in Canada and we have DVD rentals. I go to the video store almost every week, and it was on the papers that a second one (which will also rent out VHS!) is opening.

The Library does DVD rentals too, I check it out every couple of months.

It's even better in Toronto, Bay Street Video is an institution.

musha68ktoday at 12:13 PM

*UHD BluRay rentals but yes, hard agree. Also a great place to socialize and talk about which movie to rent traditionally.

0xEFtoday at 11:24 AM

Eh, I miss video rental stores in the US, but I don't agree that they would solve this problem. I worked for a large chain of them as a teen, and know first-hand that people were spending just as much on rentals as they do with subscription services, especially when you add in game rentals and late fees.

More importantly, it does not solve the problem of ownership. We don't own a rented disc just as much as we don't own a DRM-controlled digital purchase that can only be accessed via the subscription portal it was purchased on.