logoalt Hacker News

smashers1114today at 5:25 PM7 repliesview on HN

FYI a quick fix for claudish is to ask for the response to be in ASD-STE100 (Simple Technical English). Then it is far more readable. But I would agree that this is an annoyance and shouldn't require user workaround to get something readable.


Replies

a2damtoday at 6:50 PM

I think this is more a meme than anything else, for a couple reasons:

First, after a while it's just as grating as Claudeish. Second, my hunch is that it constricts the actual thinking of the LLM, like the same way that Newspeak does in 1984. It shrinks the range of thought that can be expressed if used as an input.

I think the real way to do it is to have another Claude entirely deal with the user as a liaison, but to keep the thinking in whatever format it came in.

Latent space reasoning, if you think about it, is exactly this to a crazy degree: why even formulate a thought as words if you can just keep it as matmuls until the user needs it? And then, if the user needs it, have it always specifically formulated for the user by another LLM rather than constrict its range of thought? Anyway, that's my take.

show 4 replies
_boffin_today at 5:31 PM

Does not work for Claude, at least for me and I put it as the system prompt

show 4 replies
BatteryMountaintoday at 7:53 PM

I tell mine to address me as a tech priest of the adeptus mechanicus. Works great.

SoMomentarytoday at 7:11 PM

I created a custom output style based on this (borrowing some from github.com/AminBlg/SimpleEnglish) and I've found it to be better than the default or concise output styles, but still not as good for me as current GPT or Gemini models when it comes to communicating.

el_benhameentoday at 6:57 PM

I tried this a while back and I felt like the result was the same weird shoehorning of ideas into language, just with a different vocabulary. I’d really like for it to work, though.

snapplebobappletoday at 5:37 PM

This fixed claude! Thanks!

guluartetoday at 8:19 PM

I put this rule in my CLAUDE.md: "Always write a TLDR in layman terms", it seems to do the trick