logoalt Hacker News

zdragnar • yesterday at 10:40 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

I'd love to see some source for this, because from what I've seen, 59% of undocumented immigrants receive some form of welfare (the state of California spends roughly $10 billion a year alone on this) and documented migrants are at roughly the same rate, double the native born population's rate of 28%.


Replies

mullingitover • yesterday at 10:57 PM

> I'd love to see some source for this [proceeds to throw out a bunch of source-free numbers]

I looked up the source for these numbers.

It's the Center for Immigration Studies, and they are notorious for being a right-wing think tank used to dress up up anti-immigration policy using misleading statistics.

How notorious are they? Well, they are listed as a hate group with the Southern Poverty Law Center[1].

The numbers you're citing aren't 'welfare,' the biggest thing is using the education system. The thing that, long term, makes they into productive taxpayers. CIS doesn't figure the long-term benefits into their numbers because that would destroy their thesis.

[1] https://www.splcenter.org/resources/extremist-files/center-i...

➕ show 2 replies
lokar • yesterday at 10:45 PM

Not hard to find, here is a right wing, anti-immigrant anti-service source:

https://www.cato.org/blog/immigrants-still-use-much-less-wel...

➕ show 1 reply