logoalt Hacker News

miltonlost • today at 1:55 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

Now, you just need to use someone else's words and someone else's AI built on everyone else's stolen art! But sure, yes, thats you being creative... Don't use your imagination at all.


Replies

kimbernator • today at 2:07 PM

There are three main categories of AI ethical dilemmas for me:

1. IP infringement

2. Climate impact

3. Cultural impact

I think that 2 & 3 apply to all AI right now - artistic, coding, writing, whatever. However, I don't think that #1 applies to everything. Code has been openly shared for as long as it's been possible to do so. There have probably been cases where AI trained on closed-source code, but I hardly believe that was ever necessary at any point to get where we are.

My point in saying this is that your critique of AI is valid but I think a little less so here.

➕ show 1 reply
schnebbau • today at 1:58 PM

I totally understand. I'm a developer with almost 20 years experience myself and it has taken me a while to come to terms with this too. Fortunately, I made enough during the good times to see me out once my job ceases to exist. I'm sorry for everyone who didn't.

gafferongames • today at 1:58 PM

Or, you can use your imagination building on top of the sum of all human knowledge distilled into a language model. Your choice.