logoalt Hacker News

phendrenad2 • today at 4:52 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

That's never going to happen. Game companies are not going to give you their source code. Usually the source of any game that gets shut down is shared with games that are still live. Example: if Fallout 76 is shut down, Bethesda giving you their source would essentially be giving you the source to Skyrim also. I'm not saying that I have the solution or that your idea isn't good on some level, but we have to be realistic.

Counterpoint: maybe we could make proprietary software illegal, and make everything GPL so we can just request the source code to anything we want. With enough eyes all bugs are shallow, so why wouldn't banks and nuclear reactors want their source to be audited by the public? lol

(Software might become de facto open source with AI decomp anyway)


Replies

saghm • today at 5:17 PM

>> They need to make the server binaries available, along with client functionality to let you choose a server.

> Game companies are not going to give you their source code.

Okay but what about the thing they actually proposed?

➕ show 1 reply
Razengan • today at 5:40 PM

> That's never going to happen. Game companies are not going to give you their source code.

We don't need them to; AI can reverse engineer most shit now.

Even if US lobbying tries to hamper that, China will accelerate it.

SoftTalker • today at 5:07 PM

Well then they can simply not shut down the old games.

> Software might become de facto open source with AI decomp anyway

Agreed.

stale2002 • today at 5:26 PM

> That's never going to happen. Game companies are not going to give you their source code.

Sure they will. They can be forced to by the government which is society's monopoly on violence.

> but we have to be realistic.

No we don't. We can just force companies to do it, using the threat of the law.