Well if we're comparing I've been here a bit longer.

I would make two points here.

1. ICE is breaking the law in many, many different ways. It is not legal to murder multiple US citizens like Alex Pretti and Renee Good. The conditions of their internment camps (I will use the euphemism as I suspect you would not like the more accurate term) are not legal. And many, many other issues, please see:

https://www.aclu.org/news/immigrants-rights/we-documented-12...

https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/fact-sheet/ice-cb...

https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-administration-has-de...

https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/courts-have-ruled-4...

By your legalist moral standards, is this not also "black and white"? Do people not have a right or duty to protest it?

2. What is legal is not always what is morally right. The comments you are making mirror those in past "legal" civil rights violations at scale. The same arguments were made against the civil rights movement in the 60s, anti apartheid movement, and pretty much every civil rights movement. The answer in all of those cases is the same: what is legal does not determine what is morally right, and we have a civic duty to nonviolent protest when the two conflict. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_Kohlberg%27s_stages_o...

Should the paramedics be the one arresting the people impeding their function? If the answer is no, then ICE shouldnt be tracking people they think might impede their function.

If their job is arresting people in the country illegaly, any other matter of public safety should be handled by the correct institution at local or federal police level. Hint, its not ICE.

> if there's a government agency whose job it is to deport people in a country illegally

This antecedent is false, so we don’t even need to read the consequent.

ICE arguably has a mandate for aggressive deportation. The Trump campaign did not sugarcoat what their goal was. And people still voted for that. Still, the lack of due process, the excessive use of force, deporting people to random countries, ... that's not normal.

> If police arrest criminals, and people impede the police arresting criminals

It did not happened. What happened was police committing crimes and people making videos of it.

> If paramedics help casualties, and people impede the paramedics helping casualties

It did not happened. However, police and ICE did in fact intentionally impede the paramedics helping casualties on multiple occasions.

> if there's a government agency whose job it is to deport people in a country illegally,

Following you so far

> and they do that,

Yeah, that's where you fucked up. That's not what ICE is doing that everyone is upset about. It's the locking up, deporting, and killing of people who are here legally, they just happen to be brown.