logoalt Hacker News

joshstrange • today at 2:03 PM • 6 replies • view on HN

Where is the line? "AI" is completely arbitrary, might as well say a calculator is immoral because it offloads thinking. That my main issue with these people is that they think AI/LLMs are different than everything that came before them, yes they are more capable but all of computing has involved "offloading" effort/thought to computers. `


Replies

bunderbunder • today at 2:07 PM

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sorites_paradox#Continuum_fall...

A continuum is not isomorphic to a single point.

➕ show 3 replies
newsoftheday • today at 4:28 PM

> my main issue with these people is that they think

This reminds me of the torch lighters in a classic Frankenstein movie.

> all of computing has involved "offloading" effort/thought to computers.

Effort yes, thought no, not until recent years.

jfyi • today at 2:28 PM

The average person was able to look at the devices up until now and see a tool. Now they see something they don't understand, but sure does seem smarter than they are, and has the aesthetics of being a person on the other side of the computer.

Do you think this guy has the technical depth to make these connections? He's working off what he can see, and he will likely grow old and die still lacking that understanding. So will a vast majority of users of these services.

What you are seeing is people realigning with a baseline of their reality. They have to trust what they are being told on this by someone, and they need to figure out who and how amid malicious actors that are trying to bend their beliefs.

1899-12-30 • today at 2:28 PM

They did ban calculators in the Butlerian Jihad.

perching_aix • today at 2:26 PM

[dead]

square_usual • today at 2:05 PM

Yeah, and is this person going to turn down becoming a manager, ever, because they'll have to delegate the actual solution to someone else? Or are they going to micromanage them due to their ethical commitments?

➕ show 2 replies