logoalt Hacker News

43k+ new periodic solutions to the three body problem found by volunteers

14 points • by threebodyorbits • last Saturday at 5:06 PM • 3 comments • view on HN

Comments

Gravityloss • today at 8:26 AM

Thinking about real astronomical three bodies, I assume many of these would not be possible because of too high tidal forces, preventing the bodies from ever becoming solid, or breaking up if forming by capture.

So perhaps a feature for searching by limiting tidal forces? Don't know what other limits there are making some of these more and some less likely to exist in the real world?

threebodyorbits • last Saturday at 5:06 PM

At this website, users can contribute compute towards finding new periodic solutions to the three body problem via their browsers. Out of nearly 20 billion orbits tested so far, ~43k returned to their starting positions. The hit rate is ~0.0002%. The discovered orbits can be explored at https://www.threebodyorbits.com/hunt/garden

don_esteban • today at 8:45 AM

How does this handle the limits of computational precision?

The way I understand it, three body problem is quite chaotic (small changes can have over time extreme consequences).

Hence, computing at finite precision might produce a 'cyclic solution' to the three body problem that is in physical reality (ha, assuming the gravity is truly contiguous with infinite precision) not really cyclic (even excluding things like tides).