logoalt Hacker News

rudolftheone • today at 1:04 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

I wonder: the very same model of the coffeehouse had existed in the Ottoman Empire (where it originated) since the 16th century, yet it did not spark a scientific revolution.

Maybe English scientists were already prepared for such a change in science and coffeehouses just made it possible as a simple catalyst?


Replies

rorytbyrne • today at 1:31 PM

I'm not a historian, but I think the scientific revolution partly came from protestantism -> the desire to read the bible (rather than hear it interpreted by a priest) -> the printing press.

ba1afd89f34cb23 • today at 2:08 PM

The bottom of page 32 in the paper (with more details in footnote 56) seems to address this: in the Ottoman empire, coffee houses were an institution of the ruler, which led to them being a rightly controlled environment, sometimes even closed in fear of them being used to plot sedition. To give rise to science, the scene in coffee houses needed to be independent, which wasn't present in the Ottoman empire. That seems plausible.

➕ show 1 reply