logoalt Hacker News

pocksuppet • today at 5:28 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Just another way we are above the planet's carrying capacity


Replies

schiffern • today at 5:33 PM

We agree on the conclusion, however I don't follow that exact chain of logic.

If the sewage treatment plants can't pay for themselves, scaling up or down doesn't really help with that.[0] You're just getting more or fewer copies of the same unsustainable technology.

We are above carrying capacity, I agree. But even if we weren't, we would still need to fix our ruinously expensive sewage technology.

[0] counterpoint: if there's only one town on Earth you could just dump untreated sewage and it's no big deal, but I doubt 'human population crash' is the solution we want...

➕ show 1 reply