logoalt Hacker News

viraptor • today at 2:38 AM • 3 replies • view on HN

What's people's general feeling about C4? I've tried it a few times, but then up just annoyed by the strict model - everything I actually want to show ends up being a custom dynamic + fighting the include/exclude system. At that point I'd rather do a custom diagram in excalidraw that actually communicates just the things I want... and accept it won't get updated automatically.

Does it work well as designed in some environments?


Replies

aqula • today at 7:30 AM

I think maintaining diagrams is painful as it is, and doing so in a rigid template, even more so. I'm experimenting with generating C4 like diagrams directly from code. Would love to hear your thoughts - https://arcaide.foo

billyp-rva • today at 3:37 AM

In my opinion, most are better served sticking with concrete resources [0] rather than trying to map things to C4's abstractions. Today we have so many kinds of things (especially cloud resources) that are already named and people know what they are and what they are for. Adding C4 on top mostly just obscures them, I think.

[0] https://www.ilograph.com/blog/posts/concrete-diagramming-mod...

oliveralbertini • today at 2:45 AM

[flagged]