logoalt Hacker News

azuanrb • today at 8:02 PM • 12 replies • view on HN

I find it interesting how comments on OpenAI release threads often favour Anthropic, while comments on Anthropic release threads favour OpenAI. Maybe criticism just attracts more attention. A lot of the comments here seem to be about other models, with little discussion of the ones actually being released.

Neither provider’s models are perfect, but they keep pushing each other forward. As an individual, it’s relatively easy to switch between them. At a large company, you’re often committed to one provider for a long time, so some of us come to these threads hoping for useful discussion about getting the most out of the models we have access to.


Replies

booty • today at 9:27 PM

I've found this to also be true on their respective subreddits. They both have very "the sky is falling!!!!" vibes. Two of the truest truisms are at work:

1. If you make an app, most of the happy users say nothing. Whereas seemingly all of the unhappy users will be vocal complainers.

2. The grass is always greener on the other side of the fence.

I feel the "grass is greener" mentality is particularly silly in this case, because for an extra $20/month you can just keep a cheap subscription to the "other" one. I realize not everybody has $20/month, but I think most people who can afford <= $20 for one subscription can probably afford another $20/mo for the other one.

➕ show 2 replies
yfontana • today at 8:38 PM

Yeah, but that's also probably because it's hard to have an informed opinion right after a new model just came out.

➕ show 3 replies
slibhb • today at 8:21 PM

It is interesting how opinionated people are about which company/model is better. I think this is probably because they are scared of missing out, have invested in one set of models, and therefore want to promote those models. Basically, they're reassuring themselves.

My sense is that the OIA/Anthropi/Google frontier models are pretty similar in their capabilities.

➕ show 3 replies
seizethecheese • today at 8:52 PM

> A lot of the comments here seem to be about other models, with little discussion of the ones actually being released.

To me that’s a sign of an authentic discussion. When I see social media full of comments about a model nobody could use until that moment, it’s obvious that labs are seeding release content.

➕ show 1 reply
pama • today at 9:13 PM

One important reason is that users of a codex or claude tend to immediately spend a lot of time using the new models upon release.

asdfman123 • today at 8:56 PM

Sol lucet omnibus (the sun shines for everyone)

➕ show 1 reply
1659447091 • today at 9:55 PM

> some of us come to these threads hoping for useful discussion about getting the most out of the models we have access to

`gpt` is the the overly pedantic team member that no one invites to game night, while `claude` is the "idea" person and the reason company meetings now requires a meticulously scoped itinerary down to the minute. If you know how to work with both types and which type of work each is better suited for each, you can get a lot more out of them. As another comment made: gpt is depth-first, while claude is breadth-first.

Re-using agent files doesnt work. Give claude detailed task boundaries about what a feature should do (and only do) and then a hard config setup. For gpt you tell it the feature scope in noraml discussion terms without worrying about coming back to find a simple rest crud form is now a single page web-app -- even though your users instructions say no javascript -- with 50 ways to ingest a 6 field form that step over each other and looks like it works but probably has bugs waiting to bite you.

For claude: strong settings, well designed hooks, skills, linters and code checkers fully set up to your standard, and a rules & standards system that is emphasized in every single instruction and agent file. Also a standards agent or skill that is used with a critique/review run that is a requirement of the `/goal` (this can go in a hook too).

For gpt: that isnt as important or needed and will probably start to piss you off because of how literal it is. Your rule for online activity: Respect robots.txt; ask the agent to use clojure cli with deps.edn to add a library; agent replies (the dependency repository's) robots.txt says it does not allow automated access. Explain to the agent that means bots and web crawlers not resolving a dependency from the dependency repository. So less really is more. Instructions and prompts is where verbosity helps. Tell it you want a 6 field rest crud form and it will make a 6 field rest crud form. It will also give you directories full of measurements and checks and performance for each one of those 6 form fields. Restrict it at the user instructions and task level spec. If you dont want all 50 checks for each form field, tell exactly what you don't want in its instructions. It's a fine line but the pedantic types will probably love it.

Grimburger • today at 9:49 PM

Having a top tier sub with both, as much as I like it Astra runs out a lot quicker every single week.

Maybe this will change after the IPO but for now, should probably put the money into Anthropic for another account and get more out of it while it lasts.

They seems to be adjusting expectations properly for the real world after everyone getting hooked on all these various companies cyberpunk drugs

pixelready • today at 9:38 PM

As most devs settle into a routine with AI, the exciting experimental phase will wear off and this will just turn into tribal Mac OS vs Windows discussions, with the Linux crowd shouting from the corner about how they’re both wrong.

iLoveOncall • today at 9:57 PM

> I find it interesting how comments on OpenAI release threads often favour Anthropic, while comments on Anthropic release threads favour OpenAI. Maybe criticism just attracts more attention.

Or maybe Anthropic does astroturfing on OpenAI release threads and OpenAI does astroturfing on Anthropic release threads?

HackerNews is being botted to death since a year or two.

➕ show 1 reply
Imustaskforhelp • today at 8:30 PM

Haha very interesting observation, I think that there is a challenge to status quo.

Just my 2 cents:

I think that our first reactions to seeing these companies model releases is that of skepticism and somewhat rightfully so because these companies have done a lot of things to burn a lot of trust.

But AI is still important and so if someone is on Anthropic, they might feel as if Opus 5.5/Fable 5.2 is good and so if OAI is saying Astra 6.2 is better/comparable to them, a persons first instinct is to not trust OAI which might mean siding with Anthropic.

And if Anthropic releases a model, then there would be more discussions on pricing because somehow that is also related to bubble popping. I mean, supposing I can get good enough model at 10x the cheaper price of Anthropic from OAI for very marginal points, ofc people will comment about that as well.

And within both the threads we will find an intersection of discussion of open-weights models as well.

But maybe this is that if a model is just released and as such we are not having real use and word of mouth after real use from other people (which takes time), so our first instincts is to not trust any of the company so much and benchmarks can be cheated through and sometimes inaccurate of real world usage so we are in for a surprise when a new model drops and so we just drop back to those first reactions that I mentioned previously.

But this was a good question that you asked! and I would be curious to hear other person's observations

but mine (TLDR) is that: people distrust both OAI/ANT and other AI companies in HN. (Maybe we are technical people and we tend to look beyond the BS of marketing and so we think that we wont be impacted by that BS so we want to call out that BS but we dont know for sure if its BS or not but judging by the fact that these AI companies have incredibly low trusts, we as default don't really trust them and consider them BS and so the chain follows.)

HN audience is a tough audience to satisfy from first impressions (real world usage imo becomes a much better indicator and we do see it as people mention other models in this thread and others) ;)

RetardedBastard • today at 8:53 PM

[dead]