How do you all feel about the situation?
Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
Is it okay that they are replacing our jobs with tech that would never have existed had they not taken all that work? (or would have moved slower)
Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
What do you think will happen if these companies become profitable? Do you think it will have a positive effect on our society?
Personally I feel that I'm living with severe chronic cognitive dissonance - and have been for many months at this point. But I'm not sure what I can do, I have rent to pay and children to feed.
Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?
Conflicted is how I feel. The tools are undoubtedly useful, I feel like I work on more intersting problems day to day now (rather than churning out boiler plate code) and will help us make technological progress that will benefit all of humanity (provided the benefit is distributed), and while I wish I'd chosen a career as a carpenter, because wood doesn't change like tech in the computer world does, I'm up for the challenge of figuring out how to adapt. But not everyone is, and the change, and the vacuuming up and re-vendoring of data (I'm not sure whether it's theft or not) is at best undemocratic - even national boundaries didn't stand a chance at controlling this. Ironically it was probably a predictable outcome of an 'open' internet.
> Do you all just not have this feeling?
I certainly do.
> How do you combat it?
I handed my notice in last Friday. The newest CEO wants "AI at the heart of everything we do" and so it is at the heart of my departure. Actually I've been unhappy in tech since 2020, full time remote work is bad for my mental health and even though I go into the office I'm still remote because most of the people I work with are elsewhere. I never wanted to work for a large company (and refused job offers for more money for that reason in the post) for similar reasons and have been "forced" into that as we were bought by an international outfit just over a year ago. AI is just the final bale of hay.
This is professional suicide for me, of course. I'm not qualified for anything else that isn't also going to be remote, fully AI infused, or both, so for some time at least I'll most likely end up stacking shelves or waiting tables for a third (maybe a half with long hours) of what I have been earning. I have the luxury of a paid mortgage (it is a small flat, but it is all mine), no debts, some savings, and no dependents other than the cats - others are not so lucky so couldn't make this choice even if they wanted to.
I don't like hearing that AI is bringing you and the article's author hardship. But I think it's more complicated than tech companies taking away work through greed. Technological progress is the culprit here and this time you're the victim, unfortunately.
That site's business model is similar to the many paper magazines you'd get for free in tourist welcome centers, hotels and on the street. Companies (usually very small) who published those guides got replaced by the website. Some small publisher likely felt the same a few years ago.
A family member used to own a magazine about arts and crafts that went bankrupt because of Youtube creators and free Internet articles - well before AI. It was a small magazine and profits were just enough to maintain a middle-class lifestyle. Random people online, relying on technology, destroyed his livelihood and he has been struggling ever since.
You can try using laws and spreading the word against progress, but it's certain you'll lose in the end. I'm not saying it's not worth it because you may delay it long enough to give you time to settle elsewhere, but change will come against our will.
In this specific case there is quite a simple solution, google (and oai/anthropic as well) should share revenue with the website they scrape to provide the ai summaries, they literally did this with adsense and youtube!
Sure, there's some technical hurdles, like identifying who's actually using the info they read, but impressions are a thing in ad networks, then there's broader questions about evaluating what training data was useful and used to ultimately produce what token, I'm still just taking about the kind of ai summaries in search related to the article, seems doable with the same system we use for ad networks.
When it comes to coding and more generalized knowledge there's already been interpretations about copyright laws and fair use that seem to allow what oai and ant are doing and how they are capitalizing on it, doesn't mean we should rethink them.
I'm sure there are technical solutions that can be translated to this sort of issues as well that could be derived from ad networks, I mean, imagine a world where your code and your blog post get a score on their usefulness to train LLMs and you get a share of the revenue, wouldn't this be better for all players? they get good training data, we get paid for it.
We're all sorry for the other guy when he loses his job to a machine. When it comes to your job, that's different. And it always will be different.
McCoy, Star Trek, 1968
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
That depends on what you mean by "us".
Companies are paying taxes. Should they be paying more taxes? I really have no clue. Probably, as labor share of income decreases.
Should companies instead pay "us" (as in: creators) directly? I think here the issue is mostly that we are in unprecedented territory.
What needs to be paid for? What is okay to do with content that other people produced under a different regime? The rules so far have been pretty lax and in fact we are happy to share the knowledge, because it benefits all of us.
All of a sudden we have this machine that eats it all up systematically and creates outsized effects that are hard to compete with. This seems super messy. LLMs should exist, it's just good to have them. Again, taxing the corps seems like the simple solution, but idk.
What is curious is that we had the dry run: Google got rich and made people rich by linking to other peoples information. This to me is the same thing from a different angle. Who allowed Google to systematically index all this information? Well, nobody, but also nobody explicitly disallowed it, because nobody thought of it being a thing.
Then there is a separate question: What happens with those taxes in the future? Should it be used to fund UBIsh things? Again, crystal ball says: Probably, because what else? Also: Why not?
Random collection of thoughts and open questions.
There is defiantly concerted action taking place to shift public perception and social norms about this. Change the rules before the average person even realizes what they are losing. That being said, the people who study the intersection of technology and society have been talking about this exact thing for 20 years.
It is not exactly brain drain but I think it has similar effect minus the benefits to the person relocating.
Instead of attracting/relocating the talent, now their knowledge is copied and it benefits the entity copying (again overwhelmingly from one region) but no payments so the source that spent the resources doesn't even benefit in the form of few remittances. Atleast the recent post about Japanese hometown tax was one solution for the brain drain problem within a country.
Yes the knowledge resource is still there but due to the search monopoly, os monopoly, mobile duopoly and other reasons it is hard to compete for visibility or free packaging of the same.
I don't know what it is, but it feels like some implied social and/or political contract has been broken.
> Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?
Yes I do have this feeling. I combat this by not paying a dime to the largest culprits (all frontier AI producers) and by recommending others to do the same.
If using AI on a large scale remains unprofitable then I hope the situation improves for everyone. The hardest part would be convincing large businesses not to use frontier AI either. Due to the large costs for businesses some have figured this out on their own already.
Months? I feel like it's been years. The weekly news cycle moves at such an insane pace. I'd love to say you can just ignore it but you can't anymore with how expensive everything is getting and how job security feels like an all time low. The only solice I have is that throughout history these cycles repeat and tend to correct themselves and the periods after the corrections tend do be the greatest times. But that doesn't make it any better living in the build up to a correction.
It's fucked
But it's here now, and that's not going to change. There is too much to gain, and the wider public doesn't care. Or even understand.
> How do you combat it?
You cannot publicly discuss the few options that might work for legal and moral reasons, but imho it'll end up like it always does when people get more and more alienated.
> How do you all feel about the situation?
It seems all the discussion revolve around the short/medium term issues, but the longer one I see that might bring back some balance is the creation of new content. Short/medium term yes the issues are what you list, the AI companies steal content, creators go bankrupt. But then how a new "All About Berlin" for a new subject emerges? As I see it the problem then will not be a new one emerges and is stolen, it's that there will be no new one altogether.
So to answer your question on how we'll combat this, I think "old" content / the web is lost, that new quality free content, be it websites, posts or Youtube videos, will dry up and move behind paywalls. Now is a difficult transition period for creators because the incentive for consumers are not yet there.
On the optimistic side, the mainstream web was already sick, it didn't wait for Google AI overview. So it might just finishes it off that dying model for creators with most of the ad and SEO industry.
This specific case is of course a net negative for society I think. At the same time... It's 100% worth the money I pay each month. It allows me to create things I couldn't on my own. It helps me learn new skills. It saves tons of time while searching.
I feel conflicted.
I should be able to read “all about berlin” and tell other people about Berlin without paying a separate license.
I should be able to share statistical results of analysis on copyright material.
And somehow the merging and scaling of those two don’t sit quite right with me.
My feelings are all over place about AI. I think the technology is amazing (in the right hands). In terms of it's capabilities.
If we are talking about application, ethical concerns then I think it fucking sucks.
The way I see it. This is the inevitable end goal of social media. The way social media grants instant gratification is the same way LLM's do just on a much larger scale. To me both of these things are connected.
We've been exploited by tech companies using fast feedback and this to me is another level of that.
I think the alternative is open source. You need to own the model you run, the data you feed, no cloud. I think it would be nice if the future is more crowdsourced training and data networks that evolve open source models. For now, I think we need to find ways to reward open weights, if that means China, so be it.
Automation has the power to make workers' lives better by producing more. That won't happen as long as the wealthy capitalists control it. It will be used to exploit and dispossess. The same thing happened in the industrial revolution. It was the labor movement that improved people's lives.
Even worse, being part of those companies, having no morals nor ethics in name of equity and a comfortable retirement plan, contrary to all of those affected by their work.
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
It's about the Google search page. Without Google, the website wouldn't have gotten any traffic in the first place.
Getting this new technology into the hands of citizens rather than a handful of companies, for example through local AI when that gets more affordable, is the way forward I think. Until then its just about learning how to use it effectively.
But at the same time it hurts me more and more thinking about the massive data collection the AI providers have at this point. People are completely unaware of the gold in form of data we are sharing to these companies. And its what keeps their wheel spinning.
I’m not sure either. Will AI be the collapse of the middle class when it replaces all jobs? Will that cause societies to collapse before institutions can find a way to respond? Or will we all get universal income and live happily ever after?
Or will AI be the collapse of the corporation? Giving rise to millions of tiny companies providing incredible products and services through the use of AI? Or will it be the collapse of small businesses?
Or will AI be the end of digital content? Making it all meaningless as we drown in a sea of AI slop? Or will AI give rise to a new era of digital content never before imagined.
I have no idea. I have little hopes in the institutions in charge of all of this. I hope for the best, prepare for the worst.
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
Isn't most work built on top of existing work? Regarding the example in the article, do you think OP opened an account at every German bank to compare them, or also relied on information from other people?
I've had this feeling multiple times over my 40 year career. First, it was the operation centers - the only place you could actually get access to a computer, which was fridge-sized, loud, noisy and expensive. Along comes the PC and my terminals are wiped away and I now have new technology to learn in order to gain access, remotely, to the computers I used to sit next to and warm myself. So, I did that.
Then, it was the PC again, new "incredible" 4GL database software arrives, replacing the million-dollar database server with a small box that sat on the side of my desk. Now every tiny office in every bodunk part of every irrelevant town can have massive relational database reports generated, running their profits up, satisfying customers that no longer need Big Metal. That profit is fun!
Then, it was compilers. The incredible onslaught of devtools meant there were tons of new things to learn again. So, I did that. "No more command line C compiler for me!", I exclaimed, and launched Turbo Pascal and Turbo C and Delphi and .. yeah. Maybe a bit too much Visual Basic, but whatever, it was RAD.
Then, Linux arrived, just when we all thought Unix was going to die and we need not keep learning new Unix things, except we do. Linux made the SBOM costs go way, way down, so .. some new things to learn, some old things to re-learn. So, I did that. (Oh, what a relief to go back to command line C compilers and things) Suddenly, we don't need Big Metal, we can do the same exact things on Little Metal.
Then, the Internet revolution arrived, and nobody wanted fancy local native things any more - everything had to be done in this new technology, even if it wasn't quite ready yet, the world was moving in that direction and we had to learn it. So, I did that. And boy, did I ship a lot of things and many profits were made.
What came next .. oh yeah, mobile! iPhone this and Android that, and all the knowledge about how to write great user interfaces was thrown out the window to be replaced with Hot New Stuff™ that the kids were using, grandad! Catch up already, sheesh! Maybe we need a bit of Big Metal for it, but yeah, the web was a great way to provide the user with an excuse to not learn how to install software and maintain their PC hygienically. So, I did that.
And now, the AI revolution is well and truly happening. So, so many new things to learn. So, I'm doing that.
I think the difference is, I've been in this game all along mostly because I love learning things, and computers have always been a mysterious box from which one can learn a great, great deal many things. I used to say "there is nothing mysterious about computers, only unknown - if its working and in front of you, its because someone, somewhere out there, knows it - so that means I can too", and that was a good maxim because it means I know assembly and multiple languages and can navigate all the layers of OSI with ease, and can invent things that others will have to catch up and learn, so .. they do that.
If you were in this for the paycheck, you're hurting. But if you're in it because you love making technology for your fellow human begins, then .. just do that. Embrace the things you don't know. Find your inner hacker spirit, and let it run world.
Get a DGX Spark, learn to use it. Learn to train models. Learn to SHIP those models to customers who will profit from using them. The data that all these other companies are using is out there for you to use, too! Don't forget that!
>Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
No, I do not. I didn't feel good about renting slots on a timeshare system, either, which is why I embraced the PC when it arrived. All the C compiling I could want, none of the bills!
It is the same as it ever was: Go local, or gtfo. Get that DGX Spark and get on with it. Next year is going to be fun! (Unless you're only in it for profit, in which case you're not gonna have a good time unless you can actually have fun, doing that which you need to do, to profit...)
We have always had problems with Big Metal trying to keep everyone sequestered and subjugated. Always. Every single one of the new revolutions I've described have been a battle against Big Metal, controlling everything.
Go local, or gtfo. Same as it ever was.
As much as I would like to have empathy let's not pretend that before it was all roses, with the top Google results basically being SEO optimized websites and Pinterest-like link aggregation. The example query "best bank in Berlin for expats" is the exact SEO hell that I'm glad I don't have to deal anymore.
There was a game and you played it well, but the game has changed, what do you want me to do? Should we also bring back the horses?
B-but I thought I was just going to be a leader planning the glorious revolution, not that I'd be forced to toil in the fields with the other kulaks!
Capitalism, but now the dagger has been pointed towards white collar.
I really wonder what the marketing of Anthropic is doing and how they were not fired after the first “AI will take your job, and youre gonna be fucked!” claims to pump AI.
Any insider know how they can simultaneously make sweeping claims about the future of society and unbelievably tonedeath about actual society?
I have this feeling. I feel a growing cognitive dissonance and AI psychosis slowly but surely overtaking my brain. At first these models were extremely useful tools that I could find joy in using and now they've become something else entirely. Now every day my brain gets fried from all the non stop junk information it is trying to decode and make useful. And at the same time i'm constantly being told that my replacement is coming for me and I should work harder.
This capitalist machine's only concern is profit. People all around me have lost their purpose to do the job. Nobody really cares anymore and we can see the effects on that. For example the recent FAA disruption or bank outages are likely a result of this exact thing on a macro scale.
Personally I'm dealing with this by detaching. I no longer use big tech products (beside apple's). No youtube, no social media, no algorithmic feeds. I try to be very mindful of my LLM usage and to use it to learn (somehow). I decided to start my own product so that nobody can have any expectations of me.
I also pulled my money away from the AI bubble. I put everything in a global ETF (part of which is AI but I couldn't find one with less AI in it). I'm voting by not paying for this. I will ABUSE all these services like openai & anthropic and the moment they raise prices I'm gone. They can kindly have fun with the aftermath of the collapse.
The single most important thing they should be spending time on is UBI. If they are so sure they are building SI how come they do not understand that people are afraid? All these geniuses with the EQ of Zuckerberg can go to some other planet.
What do you mean with "these companies".
This here is about google, abusing their monopoly. So clearly not a good effect on society, but maybe a wake up call for some. And AI in general will replace jobs, can be good, can be bad, depending if those replaced find something more meaningful.
These companies (or rather their-suite) are pathological liars.
They keep reassuring us that alignment is a very important topic. Attribution and citation were the canaries in the coal mine, as one would expect an intelligence aligned with human expectations would deem those to be indispensable. They don’t give a damn about alignment, it is not a problem they are trying to solve.
I don't feel conflicted, I have always felt that "information wants to be free" and these kind of developments are inevitable. We improvise, we adapt, we overcome. We use the new tools to achieve new things in a new reality, we just need to learn how. It's what Homo Sapiens is best at.
I do really feel bad from another angle, I feel bad about not owning my means of production, and can't wait for the time when I can host my own, as I have always done. But I can see that that is going to happen, it will just take a while. I hate that a third party can take stuff away from me, and I need to be online for it to work.
Just the fact that Muses and Dots are just free VMs with (depending on reports) 12 GB of RAM, for free gets my blood boiling a bit, they borrowed the money, took everyone's RAM supply and put it in a machine to get us hooked before squeezing value back out of us later. I did not and will not sign up for this. I want to host my own. My machines are an extension of my mind and my thoughts are my own.
The work? The information? Meh, I'll adapt. But don't touch my agency, my privacy, my (for lack of a better word) sovereignty.
The problem is that the losers here are usually sites riddled with ads and low-quality writing to begin with - festooned with promotional links to 'recommended products' and tracking cookies.
It's hard to feel bad for them.
When the press complained about google caching extracts on contents, people mostly sided with Google.
Now that it impacts the bread and butter of smaller companies or individuals it becomes not ok.
I'd say that people have probably been delusionnal to expect making a living without charging money for goods or service.
This site is full of people who voluntarily, on their own time, help these companies with their subscriptions and training. Just see the mountain of comments on every His Majesty The Frontier LLM Release submission where they write about their side projects.
They have about as much “cognitive dissonance” about their fecklessness as I have about eating meat. (the dilemma: on the one hand it is murder; on the other hand it is delicious.)
In five years everything will be bland and boring, people will start to ask about unique things and just get redirected to <ad paying company> instead. It will speed up the death of content on the open internet, it didn’t start with AI, it’s just being massively accelerated by it. Most people will be dumber and more easily tricked and controlled, others will start to distrust everything.
Everything will be worse, except for the stockholders of the gatekeepers (and their owners).
And before anyone asks, I’m using AI heavily every day.
Fwiw I feel this too and I don’t really know what to do about it.
I think this is not even specifically about AI progress.
Classic example of enshittification. In hindsight (not blaming the content creator!), relying on ads revenue from big players only worked for a while.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enshittification
It's sad, and sadly solutions to the problem are non-trivial. Cory Doctorow discusses some solutions in his book. TL;DR from memory: increased regulation, in particular anti-trust and consumer rights.
The book is definitely worth reading. It discusses the central problem of today's Internet. It's a bit wordy/repetitive on the problem description side, but still ...
The inconvenient truth is that the number of technologists asking these types of questions is on the rise because they feel threatened and are being harmed. A minority of them asked these types of questions when software was eating the world and other workers were losing their jobs.
There was a lot of arrogance. "Learn to code". "Things change". "Adapt".
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
This industry did it onto themselves with "free and open source". Do hedge funds open source their proprietary software algorithms because "free software"?
> Is it okay that they are replacing our jobs with tech that would never have existed had they not taken all that work? (or would have moved slower)
They don't care and it is self inflicted.
> Personally I feel that I'm living with severe chronic cognitive dissonance - and have been for many months at this point. But I'm not sure what I can do, I have rent to pay and children to feed.
Software engineers slowly realizing that they are the new starving artists.
> just took all our work
If your work wasn't publicly available on the internet, that could not have happened. Why did you publish anything, if you didn't want it to be used by third parties?
> Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money
Feel? What do feeling have to do with it? It is a service being offered. Relatively fast T/s without having to own the hardware and pay for the cooling. How good the deal is is another question. But feeling? Have people grown so used to free services that we're talking feeling when it comes to paying a provider now?
>Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
I find this line if argument hilarious given how much time was spent arguing copyright infringement isn't stealing and "information wants to be free!" and intellectual property rights were corporate capture... when everyone wanted to pirate movies and games.
Sure came to bite these people back in the butt, didn't it.
It’s one of the most evil technology and industry possible. Anti-human, by design. I feel terrible at the idea that I contributed a tiny bit to those company success and paid for their service. At the same time I know a good amount of people at Anthropic and they are personally awesome. But I’m convinced it is lead by a doomsday cult that doesn’t care one bit about the negative externalities they are causing
[dead]
[dead]
To be really honest I question the business sense of people putting information for free anywhere and then act surprised when it gets vacuumed up. I don't like it at all and I'd rather live in a romantic village where we all share freely and frolick in the meadows. I really, really do, but wishing for that doesn't make it so.
If your livelihood depends on a thing, guard it.
What are you trying to do ? To start a Butlerian jihad ? We cannot just roll back AI, internet, computers. So just enjoy the view, we are for quite a ride.
The question is? Without the author of All About Berlin, how will the AI know about new things happening in Berlin? It won't.
I have a deep feeling that it’ll never be for our good. The strategy is “get them addicted first”, then “remove human thinking and understanding” (junior don’t learn like we did in 2000-2010) then they’ll do whatever they want. They will provide the cloud and the code and the voice for anything software related, eating up everything that is in the middle.
We can’t escape it. They are too powerful and because there is positive side effects as well, and they know it, there will always be a debate.
I feel that, the common mindset in software that you rarely see elsewhere, like in big pharma, is to open and give knowledge very broadly. But OpenAI, Anthropic absorbed everything and are not playing along. They should have continued giving free knowledge of everything as well. That’s only fair, but that’s just one way to see it.