The market as a whole is irrational [1] and, in general, doesn't know anything that we here don't know. In fact, the market typically reacts to things in a much baser and less analytical manner.
Micron and SK Hynix are at sub-10 PE because they are run by people who are poor salesmen and don't know how to drive or ride a hype cycle. If they focused less on engineering and more on PR, media outreach, "socials," performative patent applications and gimmicks, they'd be trading at double their current valuations, or more.
It would also be worse for society. Puffery is rewarded. Thomas Carlyle's example of the seven-foot lath-and-plaster hat paraded through 19th century London. The memestock. Crypto.
[1]-Does anybody genuinely believe that Google's worth 3.43T and Anthropic is worth 1.5T? This goes beyond irrationality and into lunacy...
Google expects to make 200 billion in profit in 2026, so their PE ratio is somewhere between 15-20. You can argue if that profit is sustainable over the long term, but a PE ratio of 15-20 does not seem like lunacy to me.
The market has participants with varied and contradictory motives.
Main street investors rely on stocks to produce returns.
Large investors are willing to invest at a loss, if the investment provides control / access to a company which may augment their other investments. Sure, your $100M investment in Anthropic may lose 50% of its value, but if you turn a blind eye to it, then you may lose 100% of your $500M consulting business. The $100M investment may also include information that maybe is or isn't "insider", but maybe it's tailored to your needs and allows you to cut so much in costs in your other businesses.
(Numbers are probably grossly out of scale)
Some are paying to own the company, not to get a share of the profits.
It's trivial to make bets that the market is dramatically wrong by using long-dated options. These are multi-year-long bets at high leverage (i.e. you bet relatively little and win relatively a lot if you're right). If you are extremely confident that you are right and the market is wrong, you could use these and become rich. I would not recommend it -- the market is generally way better at valuing businesses than us casuals.
Edit: FWIW, Google at 3.4T seems almost a bargain -- not that I would go all in on it instead of just keeping my broad index funds. I'm less sure about Anthropic at 1.5T
Your guess at those valuations is as good as anyone’s. Turns out if you put lots of such anyones in a room it makes a market. If you doubt the market you doubt the wisdom of the crowd, which is very smart if you know more than everyone else (which means you know more than the market). Not impossible, but to quote a classic, it’s much easier to be first.
Hot take: Google is probably worth that much but not OAI or ANT.
Both of those are cool but what do they do ultimately? Change some stuff in a Google doc or pull a message from Slack? And where is the stickiness, because as a developer I can route my requests to a different provider with a toggle.
In a way, it is good that companies like Google own sizable stakes in ANT. While ANT is an important company, I don’t think their product is because Google has insane sticky distribution and is very hard to knock off.
ANT products are only months behind open source and half a year behind China. I can easily ditch ANT for OAI with a toggle. Even cloud isn’t this simple for primary workloads.
The underlying idea is that there is sufficient competition that people have an incentive to prevent … laziness ?
That outcome is highly dependent on the market participants performing in a specific manner.
Even then, pricing accurately during the introduction of new is impossible.
Ideally the players wouldn’t have so much cash to burn in a bonfire. This would make it easier for people with alternate positions to be a credible counter balance to excess.
Not saying anything new, just that the market isn’t good at dealing with new general purpose tech, and impaired further when there is a massive capital disparity between the bullish and bearish.
> The market as a whole is irrational [1] and, in general, doesn't know anything that we here don't know.
Yes, and? The price of stock is determined all information available about it, which is why (a) there are rules on insider trading for folks that may have non-public information, and (b) why people try to get an information edge, e.g., hedge funds using satellites:
* https://newsroom.haas.berkeley.edu/how-hedge-funds-use-satel...
It should also be noted that The Market™ is made up of different actors with different motivations: from pensions funds which want stability to generate predictable cash flow for thirty years, to day traders and algorithms that only need returns over the course of a couple of days (or hours). Do a search for the term "investor heterogeneity".
Some folks are looking at good companies (or at least good investments, which may not be the same thing), and others are looking for companies they think other people will think are good investments, a meta-game:
> A Keynesian beauty contest is a metaphorical beauty contest in which judges are rewarded for selecting the most popular choices among all judges, rather than those they may personally find the most attractive. This idea is often applied in financial markets, whereby investors could profit more by buying whichever stocks they think other investors will buy, rather than the stocks that have fundamentally the best value, because when other people buy a stock, they bid up the price, allowing an earlier investor to cash out with a profit, regardless of whether the price increases are supported by its fundamentals and theoretical arguments.
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keynesian_beauty_contest
What is the (your) purpose for investing: cash flow? growth? a game/competition/fun? Are you investing for yourself (retirement) or for others (maximum profit for funds? cash flow for retirees?)?
Depending to the answers to these questions, the actions in The Market™ can be quite rational for a particular actor depending on how they answer them (and irrational from your perspective given how you answer them). Your goals and others' goals will determine actions and what is "rational".
"Does anybody genuinely believe that Google's worth 3.43T and Anthropic is worth 1.5T? "
They control much of the information flow and therefore decisions that are made world wide. Is it not obvious to you, that this power is worth a lot?