Well this is going to be the big question going forward with all Hardware Manufacturers. The clarification of how physical equipment rights differ from underlying intellectual property rights.
In this case, do the security checks to allow authorized software to run on a console constitute TPMs protected under the DMCA?
Picofly is a clean room firmware written for an entirely separate chipset to Nintendo's Switch/2. It contains no copyrighted assets. Its explicit purpose is to allow the system to load unsigned payloads.
Is the precedent going forward that any general-purpose unlock tool that grants owners root access to hardware they legally purchased will automatically constitute unlawful trafficking in technology designed to bypass digital locks under 17 U.S.C. § 1201?
> Well this is going to be the big question going forward with all Hardware Manufacturers.
It's an ongoing part of "right to repair". Hardware manufacturers are increasingly looking into ways to extract more money and with the slowdown in performance and increase in hardware costs that means they are looking elsewhere.
These companies are almost certainly thinking of and looking towards planned obsolescence as the mechanism to force their customers to repurchase new hardware barely different from the old hardware. Sony shutting down the PS3 store is going to be the move for others.
End users hacking their hardware and making the software they purchased still usable after the obsolescence period cuts right into those plans.
TTL;DR GitHub too many DMCA. No scrutiny before turn off. Nintendo bad. Take advantage.
TL;DR It’s a broken system, further broken by companies trying to make it cheaper to handle such requests. The end result is a lot of false positives. Lawyers at Nintendo know this, and will try their luck as far as it’ll go. Even when something like this might not actually hold in the court of law (after all it’s unlikely for any indie project to sue back).
You’ve got to understand, the people flipping the switch on and off aren’t students of the law[1].
My guess is the buck was passed to a bunch of incompetent folks. They saw the repo has a low number of stars and doesn’t belong to a company, figured there was a low risk of blowback, and concluded there was no need to escalate to actual competent folks (aka in-house counsel).
They may have had a playbook, but when it comes to moderation, a lot is left to how the individual interprets the rules. The real scrutiny on their end would happen now if enough of us complain about this.
[1] AI music company claims copyright over musician's own recording, gets her YouTube video removed - https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/1xyi3bu/ai_musi...
I think that trying to deny Section 1201 covers this is almost obstinate.
Does anyone actually think that a mod chip for a DVD player allowing disc dumping would be exempt under the DMCA? DVD circumvention was basically the entire reason we have Section 1201 to begin with! There's also the aspect the statute does not differentiate, in any way, between software methods versus hardware methods for circumventing access controls.
(You may have never read the fine print, but VLC has always had a warning to US users saying their DVD decryption is probably a violation.)
The DMCA has always been weaponized as "felony contempt against business model".
Its also why for anything that interacts with a system that MIGHT be called a bypass, to host it on Gitflic.ru and tell them all to fuck right off.
In the UK this was litigated more than two decades ago. A vendor of PlayStation modchips was sued by Sony and lost. He claimed that his purpose was to allow the use of lawful game backups. Sony claimed that backups were unnecessary because they would replace any disk that developed a fault! This was a flat lie. They won the case though.
On the other hand, an Australian court ruled the other way, as did the Italians.
[1]: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/3915179.stm
[2]: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/4315172.stm