logoalt Hacker News

borzi • today at 6:00 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

AI is doing the literal opposite though, this is why the whole argument falls flat. I am now doing bigger tasks and carry more responsibility than I ever did. The repetitive tasks are automated in a couple minutes.


Replies

aurareturn • today at 6:27 PM

The skilled will become even more valuable.

There were people who managed factory lines, worked on factory line engineering, built tools around factory line, etc.

Then there were car sales men, car dealership owners, contractors who built the car dealership buildings, marketing people who marketed the cars, etc.

The economy grew because the factory line made it more efficient to transport from point A to point B and better harness energy to move goods.

zawaideh • today at 8:21 PM

How is that different from the second Industrial Revolution with the introduction of machinery? Countless people lost their jobs while those employed had more responsibility piled on and more was expected of them and they were expected to do it all faster… as fast as the machine would go.

pixl97 • today at 7:17 PM

When has any automation lead to less work?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Queen_hypothesis is kind of a play on this. When you step up an economic improvement everyone else will adapt to it and you'll have to adapt further/work harder/spend more energy to stay exactly where you are. This is why your body is more parasites and viruses by cell count than actual human cells.

Now, we can 'all' fight back against AI and stop it, at least in a country or two, but that doesn't mean some other sovereign nation won't be able to pick up the mantel and economically ruin every one else in the medium to long term.

ortusdux • today at 7:17 PM

That is because, to follow the analogy, you are the person designing/making/selling the industrial machines.