logoalt Hacker News

jader201 • today at 6:23 PM • 15 replies • view on HN

It’s not even just everything that can be transformed into bits.

Nearly everything will (eventually) be impacted.

Therapists? People are using LLMs for “free” help.

Physical trainers? Just upload a video of your workout to an LLM for tuning advice and other exercises you can focus on.

Appliance/vehicle repair? Just DIY it with an LLM.

Teachers? Just teach yourself with an LLM.

I could go on.

To be clear, I’m not saying LLMs are better at this. But just saying LLMs are impacting nearly every field.

EDIT: just to clarify some of the responses talking about full replacement -- that's not my point here. I'm talking about impacting, not replacing. Software engineering likely won't get fully replaced (anytime soon), either -- but it's definitely being impacted.


Replies

tavavex • today at 6:40 PM

The last two aren't knowledge-constrained. You could find anything you could ever need on these topics even before LLMs. The reason so many people don't DIY their repairs is because they lack the tools, time, desire to do the dirty work or are afraid they'll mess it up. For teaching, you could already teach yourself any degree, the point in education is the structure that forces you to go through with it (most people don't have the determination on their own) and to have an accreditation that someone has actually ensured you acquired the knowledge you say you did.

Fr0styMatt88 • today at 6:37 PM

Here’s hoping there’s only 24 hours in a day :)

Sure, in THEORY we can do all these things, but I suspect this fear is somewhat borne out of the same error that mashes us estimate a task will take 6 hours and then it takes a week.

We systematically underestimate the human effort needed. How many non-technical, non-interested people are going to be looking up DIY for fixing their car, buying the needed equipment, developing the skill, etc, really?

While they’re doing that, they’ll somehow also have time to produce their own movies, write their own indie games, etc, etc.

Fast food is available; people still go to restaurants. I can sketch on a piece of paper, but I still buy art. It’s technically not difficult to build a chair, but I still buy furniture, etc.

It’s going to have a massive impact for sure, but we have to temper our expectations and ground them in real, practical limits.

Definitely some interesting years ahead. Fingers crossed.

nostrademons • today at 6:50 PM

My top priority today is raising my kids, which LLMs have been stupendously unhelpful with, although they were pretty useful in setting up a home server and Jellyfin so I could give them a curated, parent-vetted set of TV shows to watch.

I think this is a very good template for what sort of skills will survive the LLM-apocalypse and what won't. LLMs are the great homogenizer. Any type of knowledge work where there is a broadly-accepted set of best practices for how to do it is gonna get outsourced to an AI.

But AI is terrible at doing anything unique, personalized, and based on your own desires, because it doesn't have your desires. It's building on a corpus of shared knowledge, but there is a large set of knowledge that is unshared, and it can't do anything for that. A large portion of business, for example, is secrets and lies, and an LLM isn't going to be able to help you much with that. At its best it can set up the frameworks and tools to help you keep secrets and tell lies.

And then a large portion of life is personal preferences, the things that make you unique and distinct from every other human, and an LLM can't help you with that either. There is a reason I don't have a nanny raise my kids, even though we could afford it. If I did that, it would be the nanny raising my kids, which defeats a lot of the point of having kids in the first place. LLMs have the same problem.

➕ show 1 reply
bliteben • today at 6:32 PM

There has basically been nothing in appliance or vehicle repair you could not google for a decade.

lukasm • today at 8:23 PM

LLMs are really bad at therapy because of sycophancy, cannot read emotions and body language, gives some generic advice. In many cases they make things worse.

My wife has a deep expertise in modern therapy* and I saw her use ChatGPT. The difference is between "I want to fetch better products" vs "modify this index to use embeddings with model XXX"

*people's mental model of therapy comes from the movies, books or TV shows. Modern therapy doesn't look like an episode of Sopranos

WarmWash • today at 6:33 PM

LLMs will be used to advance robotics and then who knows.

Nothing makes sense or is computable when human labor/knowledge has little to no value. It's a bit like an economic event horizon

➕ show 1 reply
xp84 • today at 7:00 PM

With respect to repair: it would take a massive sea change in how things are made for that to ever happen. Of course, appliances are mostly uneconomic to repair already.

Cars are too expensive to not repair, but the complexity of car repair is way too high. Even with an incredibly specific and accurate video, even one made lovingly by a knowledgeable mechanic, most repairs are beyond most people’s physical skills.

I do mostly agree with your thesis, still. Being closer to education than many other fields, though, I remain unconvinced that AI will handle children well.

College, on the other hand? For many reasons, colleges should be an existential crisis right now. Nothing about college makes sense from cost to how AI-cheating changes things, to job prospects for most majors.

wcski • today at 6:31 PM

Classic doomer vibes. If we were to quantify the impact of LLM's on teaching, auto maintenance, therapy, and trainers / PT, I don't think your thesis would hold up substantially.

betterunix2 • today at 6:50 PM

> Therapists? People are using LLMs for “free” help.

And the results are poor because the LLM does not have a face and is not reading your facial expressions or hearing the tone of your voice. We communicate with more than just the words we speak.

> Physical trainers? Just upload a video of your workout

...lol

> Appliance/vehicle repair? Just DIY it with an LLM.

"Officer you can't arrest me and impound my car, I did what the LLM told me to do. It's not my fault that a wheel fell off and my exhaust is an eerie green color!"

> Teachers? Just teach yourself with an LLM.

See above about therapy, there is more to teaching than spitting out words.

> I could go on.

You could, but at what point will you get to the few lines of work that are genuinely going to disappear because of this technology? Taxi drivers are the most obvious, and least discussed, example -- self driving cars will eliminate that entire profession over the next few decades.

ModernMech • today at 6:34 PM

If everyone could teach themselves with an LLM they would have already been doing this with the Internet, television, or books. Plenty of people can, but those who don’t find it easier to learn in school.

The real danger for teachers is society deciding people don’t need to be educated. Although that would be a problem for all of us actually.

smarf • today at 6:26 PM

The driving metric seems to be accessibility:quality and LLM accessibility is unmatched

rwyinuse • today at 7:08 PM

"Teachers? Just teach yourself with an LLM."

Good luck replacing elementary / high school teachers with LLM's. Their job is about so much more than just teaching.

cubefox • today at 6:30 PM

And it will not be limited to LLMs. In just a few years, they will likely figure out robotics and continual learning. Then all jobs are affected. I'm very worried about what's coming for all people who rely on wages to survive.

➕ show 1 reply
soaaa • today at 7:14 PM

[dead]