logoalt Hacker News

seiferteric • yesterday at 2:41 PM • 27 replies • view on HN

I am trying to understand something about the economy and AI. If AI disrupts an industry that previously had high wages and now can be automated by commodity AI products, would it not actually lower GDP in some way (initially anyway)? What I mean is, if you had an industry that was worth say $1 billion, but now that same industry could be automated and done cheaply then it is no longe worth $1 billion? In some ways this is beneficial to the economy in that has reduced the cost of this industry and so customers see a benefit of cheaper products, but how would it benefit say AI companies since they are not capturing a $1 billion industry, but instead sort of destroying a $1 billion industry? I am mainly looking at this from the perspective of the value of an AI company.. If they just keep commoditizing industries and there is ample competition between AI companies, then how is the AI company capturing value such that they would be worth as much money as people are saying they are worth (trillions of dollars)? I know that there is more to this, like freeing up this money and labor could lead to new industries etc., but how much of this will actually go to AI companies?


Replies

LarsDu88 • today at 5:35 AM

Over the long term the economy will grow. That I am 100% confident of. When you take previously scarce resources and commoditize them, the knock on effects tend to spread widely. Intelligence and automation used to be enormously expensive, and now they are becoming cheaper by the day. Right now, frontier LLMs, which I consider wildly inefficient can give you mostly functional blueprints and diagrams for working products, like basic electronics on top of the image generation and code generation that is increasingly being commoditized.

The goods and services built atop "tech" should start to become cheaper as well. For knowledge workers this is terrible, but for consumers, this is great. I think folks worrying about an economic collapse are only looking at this from the perspective of knowledge workers and not from the much larger population of consumers.

The effect on the AI companies with pure competition is to make them basically worthless unless they find ways of stifling competition. For example by banning open weight AI in the name of safety, forming a global monopoly, buying up all the RAM capacity in the world, etc. All of this stuff is going on right now.

The value is there. The true question is whether the wealth will be concentrated and captured or released and distributed. I'm in the camp the likely outcome is actually the former. A huge amount of the wealth of AI has not really been unlocked yet... consumer robotics, disease cures, universal constructor type machines. Furthermore, once we reach superintelligence, eventually someone will inevitably fuck up by letting the dam break by ablitering a model in the wrong way. This will give governments and companies rationale to lock up the best AI to develop frontier level IP.

➕ show 3 replies
FunkyMushroom • yesterday at 3:15 PM

The related economic concept here is the Broken Window Fallacy. Doing 'redundant' work doesn't improve the economy, because there's an opportunity cost doing to anything. And replacing the need to "fix broken windows" or do now-AI-automated work would free up that opportunity cost. Which is how it's worked for nearly all automation. (Though Computers are subject to long running debate about this. See the Solow Productivity Paradox)

The gigawatt-sized asterisk on all of this is that AI companies have to capture that $1 billion. Anthropic has to ten-fold increase it's revenues or it goes bankrupt under it's current commitments. It has to increase it's revenues another 10 times to reach the $10,000,000,000,000/yr revenue required to support it's current valuation.

Anthropic put their Total Addressable Market at 35% of Global GDP (~$40 trillion/yr). They're planning to capture all of the money.

The second gigawatt-sized asterisk is that because of the fine handiwork of Mr. Huang, China has made very competitive AI models available for free, so the actual ability for AI companies to capture the value of the labour they displace ends up being quite limited. Thus a problem in the predictions: Something as to break, but it is as of yet unclear what that will be. Maybe Chinese AI will be banned, maybe Anthropic & OpenAI go bankrupt.

➕ show 14 replies
somenameforme • yesterday at 4:07 PM

I think the simple answer is that it won't. Look to other tech revolutions for precedent. The biggest winners of the Industrial Revolution were not mechanical device peddlers, or even the 'super farms' that utilized those devices in an obvious way to increase efficiency/scale/etc. The biggest winners were instead the people who achieved previously unimaginable things on top of all of this.

And I think this (in our revolution) will also generalize to 'cognitive work' companies as a whole. This is why I think LLMs are going to radically (and positively) reshape the world, but in a way that relatively few seem to be predicting for now.

➕ show 1 reply
lanthissa • yesterday at 5:07 PM

“Productivity isn't everything, but, in the long run, it is almost everything."

is one of the better quotes for grounding yourself when people start talking about economic problems to big to know exactly.

to your question.

If an industry is 'worth' 1 billion, meaning it generates 1b in revenue lets say at 800m of investment.

and that drops to 80m of investment and 100m of revenue due to productivity improvements then competition, the economy is now free to invest that extra 820m in the next best productive use for that capital, while still getting exactly the same services.

If the companies investing in ai can manage 80m of investment and 300m in revenue as the end state. They're richer, the consumers getting the same service cheaper, and society is richer due to the extra 700m being used to produce other goods and services. Thats the dream.

➕ show 1 reply
cowlevel • today at 8:04 AM

Initially the product would sell for the same price as before, but it would be mostly profits instead of mostly wages. GDP would be the same.

armcat • yesterday at 3:33 PM

There is a further cascading effect. Say that a specific $100b vertical is gone or severely reduced. In the worst case all the people working in that vertical are now unemployed. These same people now have no money or very little money to purchase or invest in other industries/verticals. Which means that there is a downturn in those verticals, leading to cost cuts and employee reductions. And those people now have less money to spend on other industries/verticals. And so on it goes.

➕ show 1 reply
timacles • yesterday at 3:09 PM

Don’t forget that all the people that had the big salaries in this industry no longer have those salaries. That is money that they cannot spend that is removed from the economy.

Which is why other economic disruptors like rail roads eventually lead to economic expansions, and were net positive

It doesn’t not look like that is the case with AI. It’s going to cannibalize the economy and not bring the expansion of previous developments. Which is a sad state for humanity

➕ show 1 reply
AndrewDucker • yesterday at 2:48 PM

If they turn a non-AI $1Billion industry in to an AI $50million industry then they have destroyed that industry, made $50 million themselves, and the people who were previously spending $1Billion between them are collectively $950million better off, which they will then get to spend elsewhere.

➕ show 2 replies
WillAdams • yesterday at 2:50 PM

A good previous example of this was the computerization of publishing --- the investment costs were balanced by letting employees go (though the compositors' union bargained for sinecures) and it took at least a decade for an increase in GDP to be seen as the folks were retrained in new work, and the publishers adapted to the lower costs by increasing the breadth of book titles which were greenlit and published.

Note that this was further complicated by a change in the tax law which made the backlist a liability rather than an asset.

mywittyname • yesterday at 3:52 PM

Historically, driving down the price of a product/service drove up consumption of the product/service. So markets will tend to grow to meet demand up to a saturation point.

In some markets, AI driving down costs will drive up consumption. So people won't necessarily lose their high paying jobs, they'll just do more work. Or, at least, corporations will capture the same revenue.

However, what's really untested is what the commoditization of knowledge is going to do to society. Having an agent at your fingertips with essentially a masters degree in every subject on earth, and the ability to apply that knowledge effectively is a pandora's box.

The closest analog is what industrialization did to craftsmen. How are people going to be qualified for jobs when AI can do a better job than anyone? But I suppose that's a political issue more so than a technical/economic one.

➕ show 1 reply
throw0101c • yesterday at 4:13 PM

> I am trying to understand something about the economy and AI. If AI disrupts an industry that previously had high wages and now can be automated by commodity AI products, would it not actually lower GDP in some way (initially anyway)?

Pre-AI, if you spent $X you got A units of output; post-AI:

* if you need 'only' A units, you will spend less than $X (technically lower GDP)

* but if the limiting factor was not the desired units, but your budget, you will continue to spend $X but get >A units (same GDP)

Additionally, if each unit is less expensive, this allows the end-customers to spend less on it, and reallocate some of their budget to other things, which would keep the overall GDP the same.

➕ show 1 reply
wouldbecouldbe • yesterday at 2:59 PM

It will probably mean the AI companies will get part of that wealth from service companies in the US and pull it away from countries & companies exporting those services. Those service industries serve already "real" industries like: agriculture, construction, factories, governments, health, etc. For some countries with a service oriented industry it could be troubling. It will probably also lead to more software development for a while, but some wealth shift to AI companies will happen.

HWR_14 • yesterday at 5:04 PM

> If AI disrupts an industry that previously had high wages and now can be automated by commodity AI products, would it not actually lower GDP in some way

Yes, in the short term that's true. In the long term, the concept is that that particular activity generates less GDP, but frees up the human capital who can then grow the economy.

morpheos137 • today at 7:08 AM

Fundamentally what you are saying is true in classical economics. if ai is a productivity enhancer then it should have a deflationary effect.

kiviuq • yesterday at 4:48 PM

> about the economy and AI.

This is true for any economy, not just AI and the central contradiction of capitalism.

Automation raises profits for a brief moment until everyone else has caught up.

Once the new profit margin equalizes across an industry, competition sets in and margins shrink.

To keep margins up, labour costs need to fall further. That is why companies like Nike or Adidas produce in low-income countries. The investments in automation is such that profits can only be maintained through mass production, low wages, long working hours and raised demand through brand lock-in, classic marketing.

The current open bet is that equalization of AI technology can't be achieved across industries because of the important entry barrier: capital and compute. Monopolization should hold long enough to make the rest of the world market dependent on US AI infrastructure.

The rest will feel the devaluation of their work, they will get poorer - some straight away, some indirectly because of the shrinking customer base.

➕ show 1 reply
MiroslavPokorny • today at 6:26 AM

You are confusing some basic facts, the TechBros and software industry are not the same people, the AI industry can be worth a lot of money, and AI can be beneficial for them, but that doesnt mean everyone else is also seeing a positive.

THe primary moptivation for the Tech Bros is of course selfish, to pump and dump.

Stop pretending they are trying to help others, they are only trying to help themselves.

jmyeet • today at 5:53 AM

The example many people use is the cotton gin. When it was invented it greatly reduced the labor required for a certain part of the cotton harvesting-to-textile process. Some believed this and other labor-saving machinery would reduce the demand for slaves.

Spoiler: it had the opposite effect. Cotton became so much cheaper than demand exploded and the demand for cotton basically doubled every decade after its invention.

So AI is going to destroy certain industries and others will have much lower demand for employees. The optimistic view is that AI will be like the cotton gin. Those industries will get cheaper and demand will go up or new industries will form in their place, sort of like the telegraph, electricity, radio and the Internet created industries. The pessimistic view is that this won't happen. There will be a tipping point where labor supply will exceed demand and this will put severe downward pressure on wages and create an unemployment nightmare that we're simply not prepared for. The last time this really happened was the Great Depression and at least then, the majority of the population was rural and way more self-sufficient for food and the like, not that I want to diminish the devastating effects.

I'm in the pessimistic camp. I believe automation in general and AI in particular is destroying labor demand faster than it's being replaced. You see this with decades of stagnant real wages (in aggregate) and the net effect is that we're creating a massive wealth concentration in a handful of people.

As Alfred Henry Lewis put it in 1896, "the only barrier between us and anarchy is the last nine meals we've had." And now we live in a country with more guns than people so we'll see how that goes.

DenisM • yesterday at 3:58 PM

It would help to understand if you replaced “AI” with “mechanical loom” in your post.

weitendorf • today at 8:21 AM

This is a very common and forgiveable mistake, but you have the spending power of that $1B and the value it provides backwards. The economy doesn't "lose" $1B if one particular industry gets $1B less spent on it.

The purpose of money is to facilitate exchange of actual value between parties who both believe they are benefiting from transacting with the other party. Monetary supply is actually entirely separate from the value of the real economy it helps move around. Importantly: the $1B in spending doesn't disappear, it just gets held or spent on something else.

And when a $1b industry gets disrupted because it's no longer providing something scarce, the value of (as evidenced by demand for) whatever it was they provided hasn't necessarily changed, only how much human labor it takes to produce it (increasing the supply). Something still has to be meet that demand, which requires some incremental labor or capital that didn't exist before and somehow made it more plentiful. If there is competition to supply that thing then the price will settles on how much labor the new method requires to meet demand.

The destruction you're imagining is the "loss" of the ~$1B in transactions that consumers were previously paying to employ $1B worth of jobs. But consumers actually just have that extra $1B to spend, and people previously making about $1B now have about $1B worth of labor to direct elsewhere, either to meet existing latent demand or follow changes in aggregate demand that happen naturally as people's spending power increase.

Economies don't really lose jobs. Buyers lose demand for products, and employers lose demand for particular kinds of labor. But that doesn't mean that labor is less valuable to anybody else, just that their existing employer couldn't afford it. The same number of people with the same set of skills still want to work as before.

It's actually common for labor to increase in value even when it gets disrupted! What happens is a rebalancing of the labor market away from obsoleted industries/company/products nobody wants, towards those that leverage the disruptive technology. Concretely - why can't SaaS employees create AI products or new innovate in marketing/sales processes in other industries? They already figured out a new industry before.

What you're missing is probably this: when there isn't enough demand for employable people to find work, we can just lend (or print) more money until employers want to hire more people because it helps them serve more customers spending that money. Making it easier/cheaper to create new debt does the best job because it makes sure that the money gets spent on something that someone has a stake in not losing (IE that they actually wanted already but couldn't finance). In short: economies don't produce jobs. Jobs are what happen when demand on the labor market meets supply; and demand is effectively uncapped.

csomar • yesterday at 4:19 PM

The $1 billion is not “getting destroyed”, it’ll get spent somewhere else.

anovikov • yesterday at 3:40 PM

"Massive productivity increase that lowers the GDP" just can't happen.

logicchains • yesterday at 4:24 PM

>If AI disrupts an industry that previously had high wages and now can be automated by commodity AI products, would it not actually lower GDP in some way

If it disrupted that industry, the things produced by that industry would become cheaper (if AI didn't make it cheaper than human labor then it wouldn't have disrupted the industry in the first place), boosting everyone's purchasing power for that thing. GDP calculations try to account for this, so GDP would go up (the same way GDP calculations try to account for inflation; a single product class becoming cheaper is like localized deflation).

➕ show 2 replies
zamalek • yesterday at 4:55 PM

> In some ways this is beneficial to the economy

I've heard this framed in terms of "surplus value," a very old (Marxist) economic theory. The debate is whether AI, which is intrinsically a machine, is capable of generating it - machines classically _transfer_ value. The reason this is important is because surplus value is what a capitalist entrepreneur exploits (whether they realize it or not).

So we don't actually know whether it is good for the economy, I guess we'll find out after the bubble bursts.

zrn900 • today at 1:32 AM

> If AI disrupts an industry that previously had high wages and now can be automated by commodity AI products, would it not actually lower GDP in some way

Yeah. It does. Permanently. That's what happened when the robotics revolution decimated factory jobs. Everyone was pushed toward finance and tech jobs, but most had to go into gig work to survive. Even the tech sector was kept up by dumping endless ZIRP money on it. Now that AI is removing white-collar jobs that used to spend to keep what remained of the economy going, that's exactly what will happen:

The system will get clogged. Because no new jobs are being invented at scale. We don't have any 'AI biochip integrator' jobs. We don't have 'Human-AI Augment synchronizer' specialties. We don't have any of the jobs that the AI industry promised, leaving aside any sci-fi jobs that were predicted in the past.

Let's face it: The majority of human civilization's day-to-day work has been automated. White-collar knowledge work is being automated now. What remains is some blue-collar work like handyman and electrician jobs. They will soon be automated by AI-using small robots. Not that those sectors would support the millions who were laid off from knowledge jobs when they all try becoming plumbers or electricians anyway.

It's time to admit that what Marx predicted 150 years ago is happening. Capitalism is destroying itself with automation.

onza • today at 8:27 AM

[flagged]

ozgrakkurt • yesterday at 3:58 PM

Economy is such a pseudo science that I don't think anyone can answer this. It is just vibes all around. Bioweapons btw

27183 • yesterday at 4:09 PM

> If AI disrupts an industry..

But it hasn't, and probably won't, so it's not even worth considering.

➕ show 1 reply