logoalt Hacker News

anon291 • yesterday at 11:45 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

Fundamentals don't seem to matter. NVIDIA's bosses sex scandal is somehow making NVDA trade at 10x its PE while growing 60% YoY, while Costco trades at 40x PE at a 5% growth rate. Anthropic IPOS at 2T dollars while having a negative profit margin, and less revenue than Wal-Mart. This is ridiculous.


Replies

uptrails • yesterday at 11:57 PM

> NVIDIA's bosses sex scandal is somehow making NVDA trade at 10x its PE while growing 60% YoY, while Costco trades at 40x PE at a 5% growth rate.

How does this support your argument? I think it tells us the opposite. Nvidia's growth is short-lived and its future is uncertain - it hinges on AI spending and data center buildout continuing at the same rate, and none of the major customers being successful in developing their own chips (all are trying). Their financing deals also increase their exposure to macro shifts. Investors are (righly) pricing in that uncertainty.

In contrast, Costco is a relatively boring business, but if you invest in it, you're unlikely to lose a whole lot of money very suddenly, so a decade or two of boring growth is priced in. I assume you're cranky about your NVDA stock dropping, but fundamentals go beyond a snapshot in time.

rootusrootus • yesterday at 11:57 PM

I think Costco is growing faster than that, but obviously not at NVDA rates. The difference might be more that investors expect NVDA to face stiff competition for a lucrative market, while Costco is "old reliable" and will just keep on growing steadily every year like they have been for a long time. So NVDA's price reflects that uncertainty and Costco commands a premium?

dan_grec • today at 1:02 AM

>Anthropic IPOS at 2T dollars while having a negative profit margin, and less revenue than Wal-Mart. This is ridiculous.

Remember the stock price of a company is only partially about what it is doing today, but also a huge amount what someone speculates it will do tomorrow.

Wal-Mart has been around for a long time. How often has it doubled revenue or profit or suddenly done something extraordinary?

The odds of that are very low. The odds of ANT doing it are significantly higher.

Same reason Tesla trades higher than Toyota. One may go up a lot (or down), the other is solid as a rock.

It’s gambling, and it does actually make sense.

➕ show 1 reply
NoDodgeQuestion • yesterday at 11:48 PM

They can prove the Riemann hypothesis. Why can't they make a cup of coffee that tastes good?