logoalt Hacker News

Tuna-Fish • yesterday at 11:10 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

Corded ware part of the expansion to Europe by the Indo-European peoples. It was a combination culture, largely made up of incoming steppe herder men with local neolithic farmer women. The end state was extremely inequal in wealth and in reproductive opportunity; the steppe Y chromosomal lines didn't just replace all the local Y-lines, over a few hundred years all but one of the steppe Y-lines got eliminated.

How exactly that happened has been a topic of fierce debate. Some older narratives tended towards dramatic conquest where the conquerors killed or enslaved the existing population in a single event, resulting in overnight genetic change. More modern studies, including this one, made with better data and methods, trend towards a more gradual replacement, where men belonging to the final Y-line had ~15-20% more surviving offspring per generation than anyone else, edging out everyone else over centuries.


Replies

pasta67 • today at 4:03 AM

Neolithic Anatolian farmers had a total replacement of local population in 1000 years before Corded Ware arrived. How genocidal it was is up for debate, but for a context - Corded Ware culture spread over whole Europe 5000 years ago but y-dna ancestry associated with these cultures is much older than that and was present in Eastern Europe from 20 000 years ago, which is as native European as it gets.

gerdesj • today at 12:33 AM

Thank you for providing a properly nuanced interpretation.

The thing about population trends judged via DNA sampling is that they happen over quite long timelines.

A similar topic, closer to my home (England, UK) is the "viking invasion", and the "Saxon invasion". It's quite simply not that ... simple. There was no invasion per se. Over a few centuries quite a few people rocked up on these shores from elsewhere and settled or violently stole stuff or both.

That was after an actual invasion - Julius Caesar in 55 and 54BC and eventually Claudivs in 43AD. They'd largely buggered off by around 400AD.

You have to note that back then, you didn't have to worry about things like planning permission and that possession or "title" to land was generally 9/10ths of the "law" and possession (sorry, title) might involve a bit of violence which was perfectly legal (OK not exactly illegal, given that the Shire Reeve was pissed in a pub 50 miles away and had no idea what was going on).

By the Middle Ages, horses for war use were sodding massive and yet had no air-vents to mount your phone, nor a usable windscreen to mount a dash cam on. That's why we have no evidence of lots of history and stuff.

➕ show 2 replies