logoalt Hacker News

Toyota, Nissan, and Honda to standardize parts to lower costs

541 points • by zdw • today at 4:04 AM • 335 comments • view on HN

Comments

wcfields • today at 4:56 AM

They’re (the Japanese makers) are getting cooked by the Chinese makers like BYD who make 75%-85% of their parts in-house[1].

Depending on the car, some estimates say that only the windows and tires are the only pieces that come from outside suppliers.

[1] https://www.electrichybridvehicletechnology.com/features/fea...

➕ show 11 replies
johnohara • today at 5:02 AM

Ford and GM have been doing this since 2002 with the GM–Ford 6-speed automatic transmission [0]. The companies worked together on the design and ultimately worked with Allison Transmission on its manufacture.

One key difference between each company's implementation had to do with the shifting solenoids and the electronics. But as far as I know the actual clutch pads and gearing were the same.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GM%E2%80%93Ford_6-speed_automa...

➕ show 1 reply
jofzar • today at 4:57 AM

Makes sense, it's probably the only way they can actually compete with Chinese car manufacturers.

I feel like the title is misleading on the impact, it's actually all of the big players

> The push to simplify and lower costs comes as Japan’s seven automakers, including Toyota, Nissan, Honda, Mazda, Subaru, Mitsubishi, and Suzuki, work to fend off the increasingly competitive list of Chinese automaker

➕ show 2 replies
user20180120 • today at 5:07 AM

This will not matter when people have no jobs. How are the people without jobs/incomes going to pay for all of these cars and fuel?

➕ show 5 replies
deboulaymxf • today at 11:13 AM

Return of the keiretsu

heisenbit • today at 10:34 AM

The combined effect of focusing on assembly, outsourcing subsystems while needing to differentiate themselves leads to suppliers having more power. This worked while to volumes were high and predictable. Standardization is helping here now, especially while the future volume of any new product is still uncertain.

WorldPeas • today at 5:17 AM

Detroit tried something like this as well, mostly under the USCAR/USAMP umbrella when Japanese competition knocked them off their stools, here's some reading if you're interested:

- https://uscar.org/about/

- https://www.automotive-fleet.com/news/gm-ford-officially-sig...

it'd be interesting to see if they try something like NUMMI between Japan/China beyond the fairly simple bz3 operation they had going

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NUMMI

pmkary • today at 4:38 AM

It's interesting how optimization will eventually make everything exactly the same. And it is just starting.

➕ show 4 replies
nokeya • today at 10:47 AM

Standardised parts will be cheaper for manufacturers, but will it actually make cars cheaper for the buyers?.. That is the question.

rantigno • today at 5:44 AM

Cars might end up pretty boring, all the same features and parts. Kind of like what happened with smartphones.

On the bright side, maintenance and repairs should become much simpler.

➕ show 3 replies
dan_grec • today at 4:36 AM

I’m shocked this has not happened sooner, and I suspect US automakers will have to do the same if they hope to survive.

➕ show 2 replies
profsummergig • today at 9:33 AM

A non-OEM part for my Toyota is $50 on Amazon. I had to buy it local (because the car was already in the shop and we couldn't wait for Amazon to deliver it) from NAPA, it was $500.

Seems like there's plenty of headroom here.

➕ show 1 reply
zeristor • today at 9:52 AM

I was going to make a remark about Unipart, the spare parts company from British Leyland.

Remarkably they seem to be a British industrial success, and I’m impressed.

233mhz • today at 9:15 AM

Should have been done for decades, most car parts are basically solved, there is nothing less efficient than dozen of companies literally reinventing one by one, wasting millions to basically reach the same conclusions.

Synaesthesia • today at 8:29 AM

It's about economies of scale. If you're going to make expensive tools for parts, the more parts you can make from that tool, the better for your bottom line. That's the huge advantage Chinese companies have.

hk1337 • today at 10:20 AM

Does this include Lexus, Infiniti, and Acura?

pknerd • today at 8:09 AM

Not sure about other countries but in Pakistan, they are scammers, their local assembly plans produce 3rd rate cars, demand tons of money in return. The Chinese names like BYD and MG are taking the market share. I am glad

itomato • today at 9:44 AM

Production methodologies and themes will be the differentiator?

Hoshin Kanri vs TPS

salman10 • today at 8:27 AM

This is quite sad to see - as parts standardize so do customizations. The Iran war has taken its toll.

skyberrys • today at 5:21 AM

I could see this eventually making things easier for repair shops, instead of managing different parts for all the brands it's less complexity.

The part about keeping consistent color coding in the wires relives a mental load for repair.

mattlondon • today at 8:46 AM

In the UK Honda has just one EV with a range of 110 miles, after they discontinued their previous effort that had huge interest and hype (Honda E) yet they only gave it a similar range of approx 105 miles IIRC and so obviously no one bought them and it was quietly cancelled. I know let's repeat the same mistake!!!

At least Toyota have a range of more sensible EVs now in the UK, but they seem to be squarely aiming at the large (i.e. expensive ... Tesla Y, BMW x1 prices for example) SUV market where you're never going to compete to more premium brands in a Toyota (this is why they invented Lexus after all). Where is the 250 mile range EV Corolla or Prius for example?

Curious how it plays out for nissan given they're already just reading Renaults.

I used to only buy Hondas and Toyotas in the old days but now I've switched to other brands because they sell EVs that are usable.

kennywinker • today at 4:52 AM

Think of this the next time someone tells you competition is good for consumers… sounds they could have brought down prices at any time, if they’d cooperated, hey?

➕ show 5 replies
drnick1 • today at 4:51 AM

Perhaps the next cost saving measure should be to remove the cellular modem that nobody asked for and that shamelessly spies on drivers. Unless, of course, Toyota et al. do in fact get a kickback from dealers, insurance companies, and data brokers for invading their customers' privacy. In some of the cars these companies make, you need to either pull a fuse (best case) or take the dash apart to unplug the unwanted "bug."

➕ show 3 replies
bvanheu • today at 4:44 AM

I've always wondered why there are still 5-6 different window cleaner (i.e. Windex and equivalent). I would have thought we have figured the best product to clean window by now.

I guess it applies to car as well.

➕ show 5 replies
simonebrunozzi • today at 7:50 AM

They made a bet on hydrogen, which was stupid, and they made a specific type of bet on hybrid, which was somewhat successful, but they never went all-in on that.

They are also quite behind on car software, like the Germans.

➕ show 1 reply
diggernet • today at 4:56 AM

Cool. Can we have standardized, easily replaced "infotainment" systems back now?

➕ show 2 replies
jordanb • today at 4:35 AM

Basically Kia/Hyundai then

➕ show 1 reply
binsquare • today at 5:29 AM

Would these lower costs translate to repairs as well?

I hope so

iJohnDoe • today at 4:50 AM

Should have done it decades ago. About damn time.

➕ show 1 reply
nromiun • today at 7:20 AM

I think they are talking about engine and metal parts. Because a lot of other parts of a car is already standardized and manufactured by other companies.

tjohnell • today at 4:41 AM

What about Mazda??

➕ show 2 replies
0xbadcafebee • today at 6:29 AM

So the question then is, why didn't they do this years ago? The answer is, they didn't need to, because they knew that you would spend a lot of money on a car. A captive market keeps prices high.

yuhao2dai • today at 6:55 AM

here comes the age of Japanese slop. make parts cheaper and work worse to keep margin. worked with all of these manufacturers in Japan and the way they treat the suppliers the truck drivers tells you all you have to know about these brands and Japanese automobiles in a nutshell.

luxuryballs • today at 5:14 AM

Notable also in that historically Japanese automakers were renown for all of the advantages they due to intentionally avoiding this kind of thing.

burnt-resistor • today at 6:53 AM

So... another Nippon Denso but fewer bespoke parts.

kyleee • today at 4:29 AM

Smart, hopefully a trend between even more auto makers

a1371 • today at 5:42 AM

My gym commute time is half an hour by subway and 20 minutes with car. Today I thought to use car to shave that 10 minutes off. Bad mistake.

First, a driver was about to turn as I was catching the end of a greenlight... Let's just say I'm grateful to be in one piece.

Then, the navigation got me stuck in traffic for a train crossing. The train must have been 200 cars. I lost count. As I'm sitting there missing reading my ebook on the subway, I look around at the cars. A blue Kia hatchback with the new logo, a Mitsubishi, a few Toyotas, Hyundais.

I can't help but think these brands are already relics.

A trend under everyone's nose is public transportation, and non-car travel modes, have only gotten better. For the rest, you'll have public and private vehicles that drive you, there's car share, and what remains is a much smaller rural market.

What does each of these companies have, to respond to that? Shortages and cost overruns it seems, and not much else. Nokia was a household brand until it wasn't.

It's hard to imagine Toyota having that faith. The rest, I reckon many will fall. Don't you think?

➕ show 8 replies
speedylight • today at 8:05 AM

If Chinese EVs weren’t being suffocated by import bans and ridiculous tariffs in Europe and the U.S. these companies would absolutely be decimated. I watched a review today of a China made EV by Mrwhosetheboss and it’s absolutely insane how far ahead those cars are compared to the overpriced garbage coming out from the rest of the world.

➕ show 4 replies