logoalt Hacker News

andy_ppp • today at 9:06 AM • 4 replies • view on HN

The Chinese makers are heavily subsidised both by stealing process from Tesla and just plain old cash ($230bn since 2009) and also the ingenuity and hard work of the Chinese people. Beijing even promoted an Audi engineer to be in charge of developing EVs and supporting the businesses, we have nothing like this in the west to cut through the layers of bureaucracy in the way of doing anything useful.

But yes I guess building everything yourself cuts out the middle man but obviously if the Japanese government spent $10bn (probably in Japan more like $20bn purchasing parity) into subsidising electric vehicles parts, robotics and supply chains I'm pretty sure it would have helped. Instead the Japanese government invested about 1/10th the amount of the Chinese.

My point is saying sure the end result could be vertical integration, however it's a million different things they did and number one was getting the right person into a position of power rather than a corrupt politician.


Replies

IrishTechie • today at 9:17 AM

There’s a fairly good chance that had Japan provided funding to the likes of Toyota they would have used it to increase their funding of climate denial, anti-EV disinformation campaigns and boondoggles like hydrogen passenger cars to distract from mass roll-out of EVs.

I’m very concerned about ceding auto manufacturing to China as we are doing, but as you say there have been a lot of factors involved and some of them very much self inflicted.

CMay • today at 11:07 AM

There are pros and cons to the massive subsidies approach, but it's not magic and in a way they've been selling their limited assets off in exchange for a strategic trade imbalance that achieves neither the employment numbers they want or the sanction proofing insulation they wanted to establish before flexing in their region. In these advanced industries, it's basically a mathematical impossibility for them to erase all import dependencies, but they have done a lot to "control the means of production".

So good effort and they got some influence, but they're still left with the cons of this approach which unfortunately also means the rest of the world has to deal with it too. Regardless of their strategic aims, COVID gave people advance warning of the fragile way things have been restructured and also accentuated how insane China is in an undeniable way.

We could see Japanese automakers standardizing as primarily a cost savings, but in a way Japan is also trying to get industry ready to pivot to military manufacturing if needed the same way we have seen in some cases in the US to better prepare for World War 3. Japan is a critical component of that, because the US needs flexibility in how it interacts with China right now and Japan is helping us extend deterrence. Japan really is amazing and what they're doing is thankless.

That may or may not be one component to what the automakers are doing, but it would probably not be a popular thing to promote publicly in Japan, because of their culture. It will also be riskier in World War 3 than in World War 2, because these plants are big targets that aren't hard to hit in today's world so I think it would largely be a temporary strategy up until any conflict escalates to the point where plants are being attacked if so.

In terms of hiring, the CCP isn't unique in having engineers/technically literate people in charge of companies, you could argue it's pretty much the norm across the auto industry with some exceptions so I don't understand the point you're making there.

faangguyindia • today at 9:11 AM

>The Chinese makers are heavily subsidised both by stealing process from Tesla

Elon Musk himself claims, "you are free to clone our satellite and car manufacturing; we only file defensive patents"

➕ show 3 replies
origini • today at 10:08 AM

The industry knows by now how to build cars.

Pointing out Tesla feels overstated.