logoalt Hacker News

verisimitoday at 9:35 AM5 repliesview on HN

[flagged]


Replies

stavrostoday at 9:42 AM

Are you saying you reject the use of "we" for any group that doesn't include you?

show 3 replies
wongarsutoday at 9:53 AM

I'd assume most French would be happy with "France detected Lightning on Mars"

I read the title as equivalent to "Humanity detected Lightning on Mars", which I'm also perfectly happy with

show 2 replies
baiwltoday at 10:14 AM

Right? It wasn’t me. So was it Gizmodo, the website where this was posted?

thatjoeoverthrtoday at 10:07 AM

I assume you're downvoted for pedantry (understandable) but it is a real pattern. Whenever it's a space topic it's always "we" or "Japan" or "America". Nobody is so vague on other topics. I suspect it's a throwback to the Cold War space race when the major players did flights in a geopolitical context. If the institute's name is very long, like here, maybe "Scientists detected ..." or "Researchers ..."

show 2 replies