logoalt Hacker News

cortesofttoday at 3:44 AM2 repliesview on HN

Is this fundamentally different than just using tags on issues to separate ready to work on things from initial user submissions?


Replies

jonahxtoday at 4:43 AM

I feel like "technically, no" but "practically, yes".

Somehow the distinction of just adding a tag / using filters doesn't communicate the cultural/process distinction in the same way.

sleekesttoday at 6:36 AM

One difference is that if I submit an issue, and it requires some back and forth to figure out the actionable improvement, then suddenly the issue is very noisy.

Whereas if it goes via a Discussion first, the back and forth happens elsewhere.

Arguably an separate issue could still do this, but it being a discussion sets the expectation better.