logoalt Hacker News

tasukiyesterday at 12:19 PM3 repliesview on HN

The thing I don't understand is alphabetic ordering of albums, which is the default most everywhere. Albums of a particular artist should obviously be ordered by when they were released (I don't care whether from newest or from oldest).

It appears I'm an alien: almost none of the music players' authors care about this - they happily show albums from A to Z.

I use Clementine which can be set up to order albums by year. Any other options?


Replies

swed420yesterday at 10:43 PM

Jellyfin can order albums by year, though I assume many readers of this thread are looking for a self contained player rather than client/server setup like Jellyfin.

t-3yesterday at 4:14 PM

It's possible in mpd+ncmpcpp, but I just encode this in the filesystem hierarchy. My library is basically setup like music/artist/year album/trackno trackname. I had to spend a few hours going through by hand with perl-rename to normalize things, but after that it was great (I don't trust automatic tools to do these things after bad experiences with beetz and similar).

fainpulyesterday at 12:31 PM

It's probably not gonna help you, but that's possible in Music (macOS). There are two sorting criteria, so you could choose to sort by artist first, then for each album of a given artist sort by year. Or you can sort all albums by year, then inside each year alphabetically (album or artist) if that's what you meant.

It's a simple option to implement. But most developers without UI skills don't seem to think about stuff like that.

show 1 reply