logoalt Hacker News

GJim • today at 10:54 AM • 5 replies • view on HN

> Just start the process to ban this party already

Oh dear.

Whatever happend to Voltares "I disprove of what you say, but will defend to the death your right to say it"?

EDIT: The irony of this post being downvoted in an attempt to hide it, rather than discuss an opinion you disagree with!

EDIT2: Please understand I have no love for AfD, rather a love of open politics (let everybody hear how crazy they are!).


Replies

tgv • today at 11:17 AM

> Whatever happend to Voltares "I disprove of what you say, but will defend to the death your right to say it"?

O tempora, o mores. Back in Voltaire's (sic) days, this would have been an issue between debating gentlemen, not one of massive spreading of hate. It's the fault of media and internet, I know, but that's not so easy to stop.

Zealotux • today at 11:03 AM

Voltaire never said that. However I understand your point, the truth is Europe has been on the precipice of far-right rule for decades and the only solution the European democracies found has been to push for banning, cutting funds, censoring the beast.

Anything but address the actual issues that helped catapult them to the top.

Micanthus • today at 11:00 AM

Free speech in Germany is limited. Hate speech, nazi slogans, etc... are banned.

And regardless, banning a political party (the process for which is set in Germany's constitution) is not the same as banning its former members from speaking.

informancer • today at 11:15 AM

Well, given it is in none of his published works: nothing?

Even if the quote was correct, it is about free speech. Being elected and holding political office is beyond that.

easyThrowaway • today at 11:03 AM

It's usually superseded by "don't piss on my head and then tell me it's raining"