logoalt Hacker News

How to CAD Almost Anything

177 points • by o4c • last Tuesday at 6:29 AM • 52 comments • view on HN

Comments

mafm • today at 2:13 AM

There has been a recent explosion in open source cad options.

fluidcad appears to be a remarkably good option now - particularly for something that only started development about a year ago.

I have used freecad, solvespace and onshape for at least a hundred hours each to make some reasonably complex parts. fluidcad resolves pretty much everything I found painful about those options.

I have some more limited experience with build123d which is also nice, but just not as easy and interactive as fluidcad.

Fluidcad provides normal interactive 3d cad interface with tools like extrudes/revolves/sketches but explicitly generates code as an intermediate step to constructing geometry and the code can be edited and refactored easily.

The linking between the code and the gui works remarkably well in practice.

It’s far easier to manage parameters and constraints in fluidcad where they are written out explicitly and can be edited vs what happened in a gui-only interface like Onshape.

If you’re playing around with a semi-constrained sketch to understand kinematics onshape tends to “helpfully” add random constraints which is really annoying to identify and correct. In fluidcad everything is way more explicit and visible and clear.

I have only spent about 5 hours using fluidcad but it looks remarkably useful despite some minor rough edges. It’s pretty much exactly what I wanted onshape or build123d to be.

Solvespace is a really beautiful piece of software but quite limited. fluidcad has the same sort of nice vibes as solvespace but is way more powerful.

➕ show 2 replies
statenjason • yesterday at 11:37 PM

MangoJelly’s FreeCAD courses on YouTube took me from zero to dangerous enough to design my own prints. I appreciated his approach of modeling a part and then modeling it again with an improved method.

https://youtube.com/@MangoJellySolutions/

➕ show 1 reply
vogtb • yesterday at 11:21 PM

I learned CAD back in 2016 from a guy on YouTube with a thick german accent. Ever couple of years I've needed to do something w/ some sort of CAD, mostly FreeCAD recently. It's nice to know I've not forgotten everything, but it's also interesting to play with the variety of MCPs and agent tools for CAD out there. Dictating that I want something to have holes at such and such a size, and spread 20 degrees apart and so on is interesting, and feels like essentially the same thing, but with a very specific image of what I want in my minds eye.

The parts of this course seem generally the same to what I learned (although without the thick german accent) and probably translate equally well to the agent/mcp UX for CAD.

seemaze • today at 12:07 AM

These are great! I've been using CAD for the better part of three decades, from AutoCAD R14 to 3DS Max, SketchUP, Rhino 3D, Solidworks, Vectorworks, and now OnShape.

Parametric solid modeling (OnShape in particular) is by far the most enjoyable (for me) of the conceptual frameworks which transform ideas in to geometry, though it seems one of the most difficult to intuit for newcomers.

I highly recommend anyone interested give it a shot, there's never been a better time with more resources available to take advantage of the incredible capabilities of these tools.

➕ show 3 replies
beering • yesterday at 11:06 PM

Despite AI being able to do all this already, I still think it’s a very interesting skill to learn because almost all products around you are designed this way. For better or for worse, you will be able to see how CAD affected the design of products you touch or see.

➕ show 1 reply
binsquare • today at 3:01 AM

For phyaucal engineering, Cad wasn't particularly the bottleneck ffrom my perspective as we were able to teach young kids to cad at a pretty competent level.

The rigor behind a functional design needs to consider physics, manufacturability, and real engineering was what is considered good or great CAD

➕ show 1 reply
nightbun • today at 12:32 AM

This is weird timing.

Just yesterday I setup Claude and Claude duet so I can just snap photos of a caliper in multiple ways around an object and let opus auto generate the model. Slice it in orcaslicer. Send to printer on LAN.

Anything else I should know as I don’t want to have to do anything more than this to print items I need around the house

➕ show 2 replies
Buttons840 • today at 2:49 AM

I'm interested in 3D modelling, and I'm wondering if something like this would be adjacent enough to offer a new perspective but still be useful in art rather than just technical CAD?

➕ show 1 reply
WillAdams • today at 2:23 AM

So this has versions for:

- Solidworks

- Creo

- Fusion

- Inventor

- OnShape

- NX

Is there any possibility of it getting updated for opensource options? FreeCAD would seem to be a good fit --- I'd love to see Dune 3D get some traction as well, and I'm very hopeful for the next version of SolveSpace which will add parameterization.

vhiremath4 • yesterday at 11:26 PM

If you are using Solidworks, I highly recommend Vertanux's SW course on YouTube. It's free, has example problems, and helped me really grasp the broad basics from bottoms up to tops-down assembly, drawings, etc.

https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLROUP1bV8REQmZgDTTJ0JCanX...

xnx • yesterday at 10:59 PM

Probably a useful intro tutorial for basic traditional CAD, but I don't see any mention of photo to 3D or AI assisted CAD. Workflows must be very different now.

➕ show 2 replies
SilentM68 • today at 3:09 AM

I don't see DS CATIA on the site? :(

sneak • today at 12:12 AM

I have been building objects in Satisfactory lately and it’s the first interface I have found that seems really intuitive for making 3d shapes. Is there any modeling software that works this way (like an fps with build/delete gun) or must I just bite the bullet and adapt to blender or fusion or something? A long time ago I figured out sketchup but it turned into some sort of cloud garbage now and even back then I recall it being slightly clunky.

➕ show 1 reply
analog8374 • today at 1:16 AM

I really do prefer using a programming language for describing 3D models. Like openscad.

Yes, the openscad language is weird. Considering switching to python.

Do you relate?

➕ show 1 reply
bitwize • today at 1:53 AM

The same answer to everything else: ask Claude to do it

mrdootdoot • today at 1:02 AM

Hey Claude you got freecad and Isaac sim, shame the establishment. Build me a digital twin worthy of Mordor.