logoalt Hacker News

I can’t believe it’s 1

64 points • by ColinWright • last Monday at 7:07 PM • 63 comments • view on HN

Comments

ZeroCredibility • today at 8:50 AM

It's strange that in the US you write a bunch of nines instead of simply 0.(9) or 0,(9) like they do in some other countries.

zahlman • today at 2:36 AM

> What number should you multiply by? Whatever you pick, there will be a digit in that base, but all the others are in a different base.

I feel like it would be easier to capitalize on the intuition from the circle diagram by abandoning that multiplication idea, and just taking a limit. In particular, consider the sequence .1, .12, .123 etc. in this mixed-base system, and the differences of those values from 1; and show how to calculate the difference for a given term of the sequence; and show that this goes to 0 in the limit.

The multiplication trick is cool and all and it lets you skip trying to explain limits to people. But if you draw that circle you're already 100-epsilon% of the way to explaining limits…

bemtevi • yesterday at 1:19 PM

I think the key to this is that one should not look at 0.99999999.... as a regular decimal or a number in itself. Unlike finite decimals like 0.1235, infinitely continuing ones don't have an immediate physical interpretation. 0.9999...is just shorthand for an infinite process that in turn comes about due to the idiosyncracies of allowing infinity in the first place.

A lot of people just get confused because numbers like 0.23, 0.8, are intuitive and thus something that looks syntactically similar like 0.9999..... also feels like it should be intuitive.

But it's not. It's just something that crosses the border from the concrete into the much more abstract. Just an infinite process. Just 1.

➕ show 9 replies
jeremyscanvic • yesterday at 2:34 PM

This is a good opportunity to remind a fun property about decimal expansions (& expansions in other bases). One might intuitively think that real numbers have a unique decimal expansion but the fact that 1.000... = 0.999... disproves it. Still, it's not too difficult to show that every real number admits a unique decimal expansion _unless_ it has one that ends with a sequence of zeros or a sequence of nines. In that case it has exactly two decimal expansions. This shows that 1.000... = 0.999... is the only such quirk, all the other cases are basically the same, 232.128000... = 232.127999... for instance.

➕ show 1 reply
Wowfunhappy • yesterday at 3:51 PM

> The usual way for proving it is to say: [...]

I've always found this alternate way more intuitive:

⅓ = 0.333...

⅓ × 3 = 1

0.333... × 3 = 0.999...

I've been able to use this method to convince fifth graders who had limited algebra experience. (Instead of ×3, I used ⅓ + ⅓ + ⅓. The fifth graders knew multiplication but using addition made it slightly clearer, I thought.)

➕ show 1 reply
anlsh • today at 5:00 AM

I haven't read or understood the author's proof, but the "standard" proof probably goes like this (any corrections? anyways though, I have to admit this approach sucks all of the joy out of the blog post)

We take the standard definition of the reals as equivalence classes of Cauchy sequences.

Let a_n be the mixed-base number up to n digits, e.g. a_4 = 0.1234. Clearly it's Cauchy

Let b_n = 1 - a_n, e.g. b_4 - 0.00001

Obviously, lim n->inf (a_n + b_n) = 1

But since the sequences a and b are Cauchy, we can exchange limit and sum

1 = lim n->inf (a_n) + lim n -> inf (b_n)

But the second limit = 0, therefore the first = 1

imurray • yesterday at 1:37 PM

The wikipedia page on the "0.999... = 1" fact is good: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/0.999...

Discussed April 28, 2020, 626 comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23004086

jorjordandan • yesterday at 4:12 PM

Here's how I would prove the same fact, which I think is better and more elegant. If we were to use base 12, that would mean that 1/3 would be .4 instead of .333... which completely eliminates the confusion. .999... is just three thirds, in base 12 again .4 +.4 +.4 = 1. The whole .333 repeating thing and by extension .999... is just a result of the dumb decision to use base 10 (dumb because if you have a system for counting objects, it makes more sense to use a grouping that is divisible as many ways as possible while being small enough to grok)

➕ show 1 reply
cbolton • yesterday at 3:56 PM

All these proofs that focus on a particular example with 0.999… or 0.333… are neat but they eventually obscure the real explanation: 0.999… is just notation which by definition refers to the number you are approaching as you add digits. Everyone will agree that 0.999… is approaching 1 so there's no argument anymore.

TL;DR: as often in math, lay people struggle because they don't start with clear definitions.

prplfsh • yesterday at 3:00 PM

"I started the talk by saying I don’t want a fight, and I’ll repeat that now. So let’s take that fact as a given." that is a great line.

jeremyscanvic • yesterday at 2:21 PM

That's really cool. Seems to be the case for 0.2468... in "base" 0.3579... as well! I wonder what condition on the base makes it work.

dvh • yesterday at 4:06 PM

At uni in Statistics 101 me and my friend quickly found out that when the professor turned away from the blackboard and asked students what P(something) was, most common answer was 0 or 1.

yubblegum • yesterday at 4:24 PM

Yeah, I wanna fight.

It is not a "fact" that .999... is 1. You are assuming (!) that applying "+" or "-" to infinite terms is 'defined' but clearly it is undefined behavior.

This is trivial to see: We add d=0.000....1 to .999... Here we add 0.000001.

0.999... + d = 1.000000999.... 1.0 + d = 1.0000010000000

Now the "fact" that .999... is "1" seems contradicted given that 1+d - (.999... +d) =/= 0

Moral of the story: don't forget all formalisms have a bounded domain and there is no such thing as a universal operation.

p.s. the attempt to mystify the obvious misuse of the mathemtical functions and number representation by the progressively shifting bases in the second example is relying in the same phenomena when misapplying these arithmatic operations beyond their applicable domain.

To be perfectly clear: the 'undefined' operation that the OP relies on is subtracting .999... from 9.999... He asserts this results in 9 plus a 0/zero residual value. That 'residual value' being zero is suggested merely by the graphic representation of .999.... that was "shifted". In actual reality, the subtraction makes as much sense as subtracting infinity from infinity and claiming result is zero.

➕ show 3 replies
noduerme • yesterday at 1:30 PM

"Mixed base"?! I mean, it's a neat looking thing, 0.12345... but it's a tautology that if every digit represents the next base, and every digit increases, you're approaching 1.

➕ show 1 reply
bigfishrunning • yesterday at 2:36 PM

just to be pedantic, his base-2 proof is

  x=0.111…
  2⁢x=1.111…
  2⁢x–x=1
  x=1
Proper notation in base 2 should be

  x=0.111…
  1⁢0x=1.111…
  10x–x=1
  x=1
edit: getting the formatting right
jareklupinski • yesterday at 1:01 PM

a computer will believe anything as long as it's 1

➕ show 1 reply
darkwater • yesterday at 4:17 PM

> The usual way for proving it is to say

Well I didn't ever think about it that way and now I'm blown away. I'm lucky today!

ColinWright • yesterday at 4:21 PM

I'm disappointed that everyone here is only talking about the 0.9999... equals 1 bit, and not talking about the really fun part, which is the expansion where the n^{th} digit is in base (n+1).

I'm starting to feel like no one is reading past the initial section of the post.

imtringued • yesterday at 2:14 PM

This is purely a fact of notation though. 0.999... is defined to be a "destination" and not an ongoing process such as "lim".

So you cannot take 0.999... to the infinity-th power to get it to zero, you still get one. The issue is that you need to couple the exponent to the length of digits because the rate at which the exponent grows decides whether you go to zero or one.

➕ show 2 replies
XCSme • yesterday at 1:46 PM

> 7, in base 2, that's 31

Huh? I didn't get that conversion part. How is he doing it?

Like, how can you have a "3" in base 2?

➕ show 2 replies
alienbaby • yesterday at 1:53 PM

I dont get it. Unless you say 0.999... is 1. And then, just write 1. If you really mean something very close to one but not one, say 0.9999...

?

➕ show 2 replies